Introduction: Why Letter 6173 Lands Differently in London
Letter 6173 is the firmest of the three IRS virtual currency compliance letters, and it asks you to act by a printed "respond by" date rather than simply review your records. For an American living in Britain, that letter arrives into a more complicated life than the one the IRS template imagines. You may hold coins on a UK exchange, pay UK capital gains tax on the same disposals, and file a UK Self Assessment return every January.
At TaxYork, we prepare US and UK returns for bankers, founders and investors who hold digital assets on both sides of the Atlantic. In our experience, the letter itself is rarely the danger. Instead, the damage comes from a rushed reply: a sworn statement signed too quickly, an amended return that ignores UK tax already paid, or a deadline missed because the envelope went to an old US address. This guide explains what Letter 6173 says, how to answer it from the UK, and how to keep the IRS and HMRC versions of your crypto history consistent.
What Letter 6173 Actually Says
The published template of Letter 6173 on irs.gov opens with a blunt statement: the IRS has information that you have or had one or more accounts containing virtual currency, and you may not have met your filing and reporting duties. It reminds you that virtual currency is property for federal tax purposes, following IRS Notice 2014-21. Notably, the letter adds that the obligation applies whether the account is held in the US or abroad, which is the sentence that matters most to readers in Britain.
The original 2019 version referred to tax years 2013 to 2017, when the IRS announced in news release IR-2019-132 that more than 10,000 letters were going out. Therefore, always read the years printed on your own copy rather than relying on articles about the first wave.
How It Differs From Letters 6174 and 6174-A
Letters 6174 and 6174-A are softer. They tell you that you may have misreported, and they invite you to check, but they do not demand a reply. Letter 6173, by contrast, sets a response date and warns that the IRS may refer your account for examination if you stay silent. Consequently, it is the only one of the three that needs a written plan from day one.
Is Letter 6173 an Audit, and What Happens If You Ignore It?
A Letter 6173 is not an audit. The IRS page on voluntary compliance letters states plainly that these letters are not an audit of your return or of your failure to file one. However, the letter is a step away from one. If you do not reply by the respond-by date, the template says the IRS may refer your tax account for examination, and underpayments carry interest and penalties.
Why the Respond-By Date Is Tighter From Abroad
The letter goes to the address the IRS holds, which for many Americans in London is a parent's home or a former apartment in the US. By the time a relative forwards it, a large part of the response window can be gone. Fortunately, the letter allows you to request a 30-day extension, provided the request reaches the IRS by the original respond-by date. Furthermore, the template gives an eFax number with a 10MB limit, so you can reply from the UK without trusting the post.
Spotting a Fake Letter
Scammers now copy the format. On 30 July 2026 the IRS published a fraud alert about fake crypto letters that urge recipients to enrol in a "Digital Asset Compliance Portal" through a QR code. The IRS does not run any such portal. A genuine Letter 6173 asks for returns or a written statement by post or eFax, never for wallet keys or exchange log-ins. Therefore, verify any letter against official IRS contact details before you respond.
How the IRS Knows About Your Crypto When You Live in Britain
Most clients assume that a UK exchange account is invisible to the IRS. That assumption is usually wrong, although the route is rarely the one people expect.
The US Exchange Trail
Many Americans in London opened their first exchange account while still living in the US. US exchanges have issued information returns for years, and federal courts have enforced John Doe summonses against large US platforms. Under one such summons in the late 2010s, a single exchange handed over records for roughly 13,000 accounts. A John Doe summons, authorised under 26 U.S.C. section 7609(f), targets a class of unnamed taxpayers rather than one person, which is why many recipients of Letter 6173 cannot point to any notice they ever received. As a result, a coin bought in New York in 2017 and later moved to a UK wallet can still carry a US paper trail.
Form 1099-DA and the Next Wave
The data flow is growing. US brokers now report gross proceeds of digital asset sales on Form 1099-DA for disposals from 1 January 2025, and cost basis follows for assets acquired in the same account from 1 January 2026. The IRS explains the regime on its digital assets page, and we cover the detail in our guide to Form 1099-DA crypto reporting. Meanwhile, the yes or no digital asset question on page one of Form 1040 creates a sworn record of its own every year.
The UK Side Is Moving Too
UK exchanges do not send US forms. However, UK crypto service providers began collecting user data on 1 January 2026 under the Cryptoasset Reporting Framework, with the first report to HMRC due by 31 May 2027. Separately, HMRC is running a crypto nudge campaign from July 2026 to March 2027, as ICAEW reported, and the Chartered Institute of Taxation has explained how HMRC's one to many crypto letters work. In other words, a Letter 6173 and an HMRC nudge letter may now arrive within months of each other, about the same disposals.
The Three Ways to Answer Letter 6173
Every Letter 6173 offers three routes. You file the delinquent returns you missed, you amend the returns you got wrong, or you send a statement explaining why you were already compliant. Choosing between them is the single most important decision in the process.
Route One: File the Missing Returns
If you stopped filing US returns after moving to Britain, the letter tells you to file the missing years and report the crypto activity on them. For many readers, the crypto is the smaller problem. The real exposure is years of missed US tax returns, and possibly a missed FBAR, which is where a structured catch-up through our IRS Streamlined filing service may come into play. The IRS states that the Streamlined Filing Compliance Procedures are closed to anyone whose returns are under civil examination. Because a Letter 6173 is not itself an examination, the route can still be open when you reply on time. Nevertheless, your non-wilful certification must be accurate, and the letter becomes part of the facts you describe.
Route Two: Amend the Returns You Filed
If you filed but left out crypto disposals, which is the most common Letter 6173 scenario we see, you correct each year on Form 1040-X. The letter asks you to write "Letter 6173" at the top of the first page and to mail the originals to the Philadelphia address it gives, while sending a copy with your reply. For a UK resident, this is where most of the value lies, because the amended return can carry a foreign tax credit for UK capital gains tax already paid.
Route Three: The Sworn Statement of Compliance
If you believe you reported everything, you send a statement of facts, a complete history of the virtual currency income you reported, copies of the filings, and a declaration signed under penalties of perjury. Importantly, the template warns that the IRS will check your statement against information from banks, financial advisers and other sources. Therefore, never choose this route on memory alone. Rebuild the transaction history first, then decide.
A Four-Question Test Before You Reply
We use a short decision framework with every client who brings us a Letter 6173. It is not on any IRS page, but it prevents the most expensive mistakes.
Question One: Which Years and Which Wallets?
First, list every year printed on the letter and every exchange, wallet and platform you used in those years, including accounts you have since closed. Next, export the full transaction history, not just the annual summaries, because swaps between coins are taxable disposals for US purposes.
Question Two: What Did You Tell Each Tax Authority?
Second, compare what your US returns reported with what your UK returns reported for the same disposals. A gap on the US side alone usually means an amendment with credits. A gap on both sides means you need a coordinated plan, because HMRC has its own disclosure channel and its own deadlines.
Question Three: Were Any Foreign Accounts FBAR Reportable?
Third, check the FBAR position, because a Letter 6173 reply that fixes the income tax but ignores the FBAR leaves the larger penalty exposure open. According to FinCEN Notice 2020-2, a foreign account holding only virtual currency is not currently a reportable account. However, a UK exchange account that also holds sterling cash is a hybrid account, and it counts towards the $10,000 aggregate threshold on the FBAR filed through FinCEN. The IRS comparison of Form 8938 and FBAR rules is a useful companion, and our FBAR and FATCA reporting service handles both forms together.
Question Four: Is the Statute Still Open?
Finally, check which years the IRS can still assess under 26 U.S.C. section 6501. Normally the window is three years from filing, extended to six where you omit more than 25% of gross income, and it never starts for a year with no return. As a result, an American who stopped filing after moving to London faces no time limit on those years at all.
Reconciling the US and UK Numbers
This is the part competitor guides skip, and it is where UK-resident Americans either save or waste most of their money.
Different Cost Rules on Each Side
The two systems calculate the same gain differently. HMRC pools tokens of the same type under the share-pooling rules explained in its Cryptoassets Manual, subject to same-day and 30-day matching. The US uses specific identification or first in, first out, wallet by wallet since 1 January 2025. Furthermore, US gains are measured in dollars and UK gains in sterling, so currency movements alone can create a gain on one side and a smaller one on the other.
Claiming the Foreign Tax Credit
For a US citizen whose tax home is in Britain, a crypto gain that bears UK tax of at least 10% is treated as foreign source, so the UK capital gains tax can be claimed as a passive category foreign tax credit on Form 1116. Current UK rates are on the GOV.UK capital gains tax page. Our tax treaty optimisation service applies the US-UK treaty and the credit rules year by year. However, the 3.8% Net Investment Income Tax is the trap: the IRS position is that the foreign tax credit cannot reduce it, so a small residual US bill often survives even when UK tax was higher.
The Penalty Picture
Penalties usually matter more than tax. A qualified amended return, filed before the IRS first contacts you about an examination, can avoid the 20% accuracy-related penalty. However, Treasury Regulation section 1.6664-2 lists several events that close that window early, and whether a Letter 6173 counts as such a contact is not settled. Consequently, you should budget for the penalty and build a reasonable cause argument, rather than assume a clean slate.
Case Study: The London Banker With a Forgotten Coin
The following illustrative example uses realistic figures and rounded exchange rates.
The Facts
Claire is a US citizen and a managing director at an investment bank in London. She bought 3 bitcoin on a US exchange in 2017 for $24,000 while living in New York, then moved to London in 2019 and transferred the coins to a UK exchange. In March 2024 she sold all 3 for $195,000. Her UK accountant reported the gain on her 2023/24 Self Assessment return. However, her US preparer never saw the UK exchange statements, so her 2024 Form 1040 showed no crypto sale and she ticked "No" on the digital asset question. In September 2026 a Letter 6173 arrived at her mother's address in Connecticut, and it reached her in London with 19 days left.
The Numbers
Her US long-term gain is $171,000. At the 20% rate she owes $34,200 of regular tax, plus $6,498 of Net Investment Income Tax at 3.8%. On the UK side, her sterling cost was about £18,600 and her proceeds about £153,500, giving a gain of £134,900. After the £6,000 annual exempt amount for 2023/24, she paid UK tax at 20% of £128,900, which is £25,780, or roughly $32,740. That credit reduces her US regular tax to about $1,460. Therefore, her total additional US tax is about $7,958, plus interest.
The Reply
We filed for the 30-day extension by eFax on day two, rebuilt the wallet history, and confirmed that the UK exchange account had held more than £12,000 of sterling cash at the end of 2022 and 2023. That made it a hybrid account, so two FBARs had been missed as well. We filed an amended 2024 return with Form 1116, the two late FBARs with a reasonable cause statement, and a covering reply quoting the letter reference. Claire's instinct had been to sign the sworn statement of compliance, because her UK tax was paid. Had she done so, she would have sworn to a false return. Instead, she paid about $8,000 of tax, roughly $1,600 of accuracy-related penalty and interest, and closed the matter on both sides.
How TaxYork Can Help
We prepare complete US and UK returns for high-net-worth clients, so a Letter 6173 reply never sits in one silo.
One Team for Both Returns
Our team rebuilds digital asset histories across US and UK platforms, computes both the dollar and sterling gains, and prepares the amended or delinquent US returns with the right foreign tax credits. In addition, we check every account for missed FBAR and Form 8938 reporting, which is often the larger exposure for clients who also hold ISAs, pensions or investment accounts. Our wider guide to crypto tax for US citizens in the UK explains how the two regimes interact year to year.
Handling the HMRC Side
If the review also shows a UK shortfall, we coordinate the US reply with the HMRC route. Where a return can still be amended, that is the simplest fix. Otherwise, HMRC's service for telling it about unpaid tax on cryptoassets applies, and the timing of each disclosure matters for penalties. For broader structuring, our cross-border planning team reviews how future disposals should be held.
Conclusion
A Letter 6173 is a warning, not a verdict. It gives you a defined window to correct the record before the IRS opens an examination, and for most Americans in Britain the tax at stake is far smaller than the panic suggests, because UK capital gains tax already paid can be credited. The real risks are a missed respond-by date, an unsupported sworn statement, an overlooked FBAR on a hybrid UK exchange account, and a UK position that does not match the US one. Handle those four points carefully and the letter usually closes cleanly.
Ultimately, the right reply starts with a full transaction history and a side-by-side reconciliation of both returns. Moreover, it should be filed with time to spare, using the extension if you need it.
Contact Us
If you have received a Letter 6173, or you suspect your crypto reporting will not survive scrutiny, book a consultation with our US-UK team. We will review the letter, request any extension you need, and prepare a coordinated reply for both tax authorities.
Email hello@taxyork.com or call 020 3488 8606 to speak with the TaxYork Expert Team.
Disclaimer
This article provides general information about US and UK tax rules as at November 2026 and does not constitute tax, legal or financial advice. The case study is illustrative, uses rounded exchange rates, and does not describe a real client. Tax outcomes depend on your individual circumstances, and the rules described may change. You should obtain advice tailored to your situation from a qualified professional before acting. TaxYork accepts no liability for actions taken on the basis of this article.
