Introduction: What IRS Letter 105C Means for Americans in Britain
IRS Letter 105C is the formal notice that the IRS has refused, in full, a refund or credit you asked for, usually on an amended return. It starts a two-year period under section 6532 of the Internal Revenue Code in which you must either win the refund back from the IRS or file suit, and asking Appeals to look again does not pause that period.
Most of what you will read about this letter online concerns businesses that claimed the Employee Retention Credit. That is not who receives it in our practice. Here, the letter usually lands on the doormat of an American banker, fund partner or company owner in London who filed a Form 1040-X to claim back US tax after HMRC charged more UK tax, after a bonus was clawed back, or while a court case was running that seemed to promise money back.
At TaxYork, we prepare US and UK returns for Americans, dual nationals and accidental Americans who live in Britain, and we prepare and defend their refund claims. This guide explains what IRS Letter 105C says, how the clock works, the reasons claims from UK residents are refused, how to respond from this side of the Atlantic, and a point almost no one mentions: where an American with no US home can actually sue. A worked case study with real figures sits in the middle.
IRS Letter 105C in One Paragraph
IRS Letter 105C is titled "Claim Disallowed". It names the tax year, the amount you claimed, and a short reason for the refusal, such as a late claim or missing support. It also tells you that you may ask the IRS Independent Office of Appeals to review the decision, or sue in a federal district court or the US Court of Federal Claims. The date printed at the top right of the first page matters more than anything else in it, because the two-year period runs from that mailing date. The Taxpayer Advocate Service page on Letter 105C gives the IRS's own plain summary.
Why Claims From Britain Get Disallowed More Often
Claims from UK residents are harder for an IRS reviewer to follow. They rest on foreign tax figures in sterling, on HMRC documents the reviewer has never seen, and on treaty articles that a domestic correspondence unit rarely handles. Consequently, a perfectly sound claim can be refused simply because the reviewer could not connect your UK evidence to the line on Form 1116 for the foreign tax credit. That is good news in one sense: many refusals of this kind, including IRS Letter 105C itself, are fixable with better paperwork. However, the paperwork has to arrive, and be understood, inside a fixed window.
What Is the Difference Between Letter 105C, 106C and Letter 569?
IRS Letter 105C refuses the whole claim, while Letter 106C refuses only part of it and allows the rest. Letter 569 is different again: it comes from an examiner who proposes to refuse your claim and invites a protest first. Only a formal notice of claim disallowance, usually 105C or 106C, starts the two-year suit period.
Full and Partial Disallowance
If you asked for $40,000 and the IRS allows $15,000, you will receive Letter 106C rather than IRS Letter 105C, along with a refund for the allowed part. The two letters work in the same way for timing. Each is the statutory notice that section 6532 requires, and each must be mailed by certified or registered post for the clock to start. The Tax Adviser's analysis of the section 6532 time limit confirms that these two letters are the IRS's standard statutory notices.
The scale is larger than most people expect. The National Taxpayer Advocate reported that the IRS issued 318,957 Letters 105C and 106C in calendar year 2021 alone. In other words, IRS Letter 105C is routine paperwork for the IRS, even if it feels personal to you.
Letter 569 and the Examination Route
Before any IRS Letter 105C is issued, larger or more technical claims, such as a foreign tax credit claim running into tens of thousands of dollars, are often sent to an examiner instead of being decided at a service centre. In that case you may first receive Letter 569, which sets out a proposed disallowance and gives you a chance to file a protest before any final decision. Agreeing usually means signing a form accepting the disallowance. Because the clock has not yet started at that stage, the protest you file in response to Letter 569 does not eat into any two-year period.
Letters That Are Not Notices of Disallowance
Some IRS letters say your claim was "not considered" or ask for more information. Those are not statutory notices, so they do not start the section 6532 period. Nevertheless, treat them seriously, because ignoring a request for information is the quickest way to receive IRS Letter 105C a few months later. If you are unsure which kind of letter you hold, look for the paragraph about filing suit; a true notice of claim disallowance always explains your right to go to court.
How Long Do You Have After IRS Letter 105C?
You have two years from the date the IRS mailed IRS Letter 105C to file a refund suit, unless you and the IRS sign Form 907 to extend that period before it ends. Appeals, reconsideration and further correspondence do not stop the clock. If the two years pass with no suit and no extension, the refund is lost even if Appeals later agrees with you.
The Two-Year Clock Under Section 6532
The rule sits in section 6532(a) of the Internal Revenue Code. Paragraph (1) bars a suit filed more than two years after the IRS mails a notice of disallowance by certified or registered mail. Paragraph (2) lets you and the IRS extend that period in writing. Paragraph (3) starts the clock early if you file a written waiver of the notice. Paragraph (4) says that any reconsideration after the notice is mailed does not extend the time to sue.
So if your IRS Letter 105C is dated 7 September 2026, your last day to file suit is 7 September 2028. That date does not move because you replied, because Appeals took your case, or because the letter took three weeks to reach Kensington. Moreover, the IRS cannot simply pay you after that date out of fairness. Section 6514 treats a refund paid after the suit period has expired as erroneous, which is why Appeals generally will not decide a claim once the period has run.
Why Appeals Does Not Stop the Clock
This is the trap that catches careful people who receive IRS Letter 105C. You reply within weeks, ask for Appeals, and then wait. According to the National Taxpayer Advocate's blog on notices of claim disallowance, simply getting an Appeals Officer assigned can take six to twelve months. If Appeals sends the case back to an examiner on the merits, the cycle can start again. Two years can disappear without anyone at the IRS doing anything wrong.
Therefore, put the expiry date in your diary on the day IRS Letter 105C arrives, and set a second reminder 18 months later. At that point, either the matter is settled or you need an extension or a lawsuit.
Form 907 and Form 2297
Form 907, Agreement to Extend the Time to Bring Suit, is the written extension that section 6532(a)(2) allows. It is valid only when both you and an authorised IRS official have signed it, and only if that happens before the current period ends. You can sign more than one in sequence. If a representative acts for you under Form 2848, the authority to sign Form 907 must be within the scope of that power of attorney. The IRS will not sign an extension if it considers the original claim to have been filed late, so do not rely on Form 907 where timeliness is the issue.
Form 2297 works in the opposite direction. It is a waiver of the statutory notice, and signing it starts the two-year clock on the date the waiver is filed. Examiners sometimes put it in front of taxpayers alongside an agreement form, and a busy executive can sign it without realising they have just started a countdown. Read every form you are asked to sign after IRS Letter 105C or Letter 569, and ask what it does to the section 6532 period.
Why Did the IRS Disallow Your Refund Claim?
The most common reasons are a claim the IRS believes was filed late, a claim it believes is unsupported, and a claim that depends on a legal argument the IRS rejects. For Americans in Britain, all three appear regularly, and the first is often wrong because reviewers apply the ordinary three-year rule to foreign tax credit claims that enjoy a ten-year window.
The Three-Year Rule and the Ten-Year Foreign Tax Credit Window
Under section 6511 of the Internal Revenue Code, most refund claims must be filed within three years of the date the return was filed or two years from the date the tax was paid, whichever is later. IRS Publication 556 explains the general rule and the look-back limits on how much you can recover.
However, section 6511(d)(3) gives a special period for claims that arise from foreign tax credits. You have ten years from the original due date of the return for the year in which the foreign tax was paid or accrued. Consequently, an American in London who pays extra UK tax after an HMRC enquiry closes in 2025 can still claim the matching US credit for an old year long after the three-year deadline has passed. When IRS Letter 105C cites lateness on a foreign tax credit claim, check the ten-year rule before anything else. In our experience, it is the single most frequent error on refusals sent to UK residents.
Missing UK Evidence
The second reason behind IRS Letter 105C is evidence the reviewer could not use. A Form 1040-X that says "additional UK tax paid following HMRC enquiry" with no closure notice, no SA302 calculation and no proof of payment will often be refused as unsupported. Similarly, a claim to move from the foreign earned income exclusion to the foreign tax credit, or the reverse, can fail if the reviewer cannot see the revised Form 1116 or Form 2555 workings.
The fix is a translation exercise as much as a tax one. Show the HMRC figure in sterling, the exchange rate you used and why, the date of payment, and the line on Form 1116 where it lands. If you elected the accrual basis for foreign taxes, say so, because it changes both the year the credit belongs to and the exchange rate. Our guide to tax treaty and foreign tax credit relief covers the underlying computation.
Claims Built on Law That Has Since Changed
The third group matters this year. For several years, Americans abroad filed protective claims arguing that a treaty foreign tax credit could reduce the 3.8% net investment income tax, encouraged by Court of Federal Claims wins in the Bruyea and Christensen cases. On 31 August 2026, the Federal Circuit reversed both decisions, as KPMG's summary of the Federal Circuit NIIT rulings records. The court held that the treaty credit is subject to the limits of US law, and US law gives no credit against that tax.
Those protective claims are now being refused, and many UK residents will receive IRS Letter 105C or 106C for them over the coming months. The credit article of the US-UK income tax treaty uses the same "in accordance with" wording that the court relied on. Therefore, for most people, the realistic response to a NIIT-only disallowance is to accept it and spend the money on claims that can still win. We return to the one forum argument that remains later in this guide.
How Do You Respond to IRS Letter 105C From the UK?
Reply in writing to the address on the letter, explain why the claim should be allowed, enclose the evidence that was missing, and say clearly that you want the case sent to Appeals if the IRS does not change its mind. Keep proof of when you sent it, track the two-year date, and file Form 907 or a suit well before it expires.
Reconsideration With New Evidence
Start with the reason given in IRS Letter 105C. If the IRS says the claim was late, show the filing date and the statutory window that applies. If it says the claim was unsupported, send the support. The IRS can reverse itself at this stage without involving Appeals, and many UK claims are resolved here once a reviewer sees an HMRC closure notice and a proof of payment.
For example, a client may have claimed an extra $22,000 of credit for UK tax on a deferred bonus that vested in 2023. The refusal said "no foreign tax documentation". A reply enclosing the P60, the employer's vesting statement, the SA302 and a one-page reconciliation from sterling to dollars is often enough. Additionally, include a short covering letter that a non-specialist can follow in five minutes, because that is roughly how long the first reader will spend.
Small Case Request or Formal Protest
If you want Appeals, the form of your request depends on size. Under IRS Publication 5 on appeal rights and protests, where the total amount for any tax period is $25,000 or less you can make a small case request, which is a brief written statement. Above that, you need a formal written protest. It must list the years and items in dispute, the facts, the law you rely on and a penalties-of-perjury declaration signed by you, or by your representative with a statement about what they know.
For a high-earning household, most foreign tax credit refusals exceed $25,000 for at least one year, so assume a formal protest. Write it as if a judge might read it later, because the same facts and arguments will form the core of any refund suit.
Sending Paper From Britain Safely
Post is where overseas replies to IRS Letter 105C go wrong. The timely-mailing rule in section 7502 applies to US Postal Service postmarks and to IRS-designated private delivery services, not to a Royal Mail postmark. Therefore, use a designated courier service, keep the tracking record, and send a copy by fax where the letter gives a fax number. Our guide on how to contact the IRS from the UK lists the international phone and fax routes that work.
Equally important, keep your IRS address current. A notice of disallowance mailed by certified post to your last known address starts the clock even if it sits unread at an old flat in Manhattan. If you have moved since filing the claim, file Form 8822 straight away.
Mistakes That Cost Refunds
The first mistake after IRS Letter 105C is treating the reply as the end of the matter. Your response does not protect the claim; only an IRS-signed Form 907 or a filed suit does. The second is conceding the whole claim when only one item was weak. A claim that mixes a sound foreign tax credit item with a NIIT credit item should be split, so that the weak item does not colour the strong one. The third is ignoring the risk of a penalty. A refund claim with no reasonable basis can attract the 20% penalty for excessive claims, which we explain in our guide to the section 6676 penalty on refund claims. Finally, many people forget that penalty refund claims follow a separate route on Form 843, covered in our guide to claiming back IRS penalties with Form 843.
Case Study: IRS Letter 105C on a Foreign Tax Credit Claim
This illustrative IRS Letter 105C case uses invented people and realistic figures to show how the rules fit together. It is the sort of file we see when an HMRC enquiry and a US claim overlap.
The Claim and the Letter
Megan is a US citizen and a managing director at a London investment bank. She filed her 2022 US return on 15 June 2023, using the automatic two-month extension for taxpayers abroad. She had elected the accrual basis for foreign taxes on Form 1116 in an earlier year. In 2025, HMRC closed an enquiry into her 2022/23 return, which concerned the timing of a deferred bonus, and she paid additional UK income tax of £41,000 on 30 June 2025.
In August 2026, she filed Form 1040-X for 2022. It claimed two things. The first was an extra foreign tax credit for the £41,000. Because foreign tax paid more than two years after the end of the year it relates to must be translated at the exchange rate on the date of payment, not the yearly average, the £41,000 converted at roughly 1.37 to about $56,170. After the Form 1116 limitation, the usable additional credit was $49,800, with the balance carried forward. The second item was a protective claim for $11,400, arguing that UK tax could offset her net investment income tax. In total, she claimed $61,200.
On 7 September 2026, the IRS mailed her IRS Letter 105C. The stated reason was that the claim was filed more than three years after the original return.
Splitting the Strong Item From the Dead One
The lateness ground was wrong for the foreign tax credit item. Under section 6511(d)(3), the period for a claim arising from foreign tax that accrued in 2022 runs for ten years from the original due date of the 2022 return. That takes it into 2033. Meanwhile, the NIIT item was timely in principle but had become unwinnable on the merits after the Federal Circuit's August 2026 decisions.
Therefore, her reply to IRS Letter 105C did three things. It accepted the disallowance of the $11,400 NIIT item. It explained the ten-year rule for the $49,800 item, citing the statute. And it enclosed the HMRC closure notice, the revised SA302, the bank record of the 30 June 2025 payment, the exchange-rate source, and a revised Form 1116 reconciling every figure. Because $49,800 exceeds $25,000, the reply included a formal protest requesting Appeals if the service centre did not reverse its decision.
The Timeline That Protected the Refund
Her adviser diarised 7 September 2028 as the last day for suit and 7 March 2028 as the review point. Suppose the service centre does not reverse and the case reaches Appeals in summer 2027. If Appeals has not finished by March 2028, Megan signs a Form 907 extending the period to, say, 30 September 2029, and the Appeals Officer countersigns it before the original date passes. If the IRS refuses to sign, she files a refund suit before 7 September 2028 and continues negotiating while the case is pending.
On these facts, the expected outcome is a refund of $49,800 plus overpayment interest. The NIIT item is lost either way. What could have cost her the entire $49,800 was not the merits; it was assuming that her reply had stopped the clock. In addition, because her US claim relied on additional UK tax, she disclosed it as a foreign tax redetermination, which kept the claim consistent with her section 905(c) reporting duty.
Can You Take IRS Letter 105C to Court From Britain?
Yes, but the choice of court is narrower than the letter suggests. IRS Letter 105C mentions both a district court and the Court of Federal Claims. A district court refund suit, however, must be brought where the plaintiff resides, so an American with no US home may be left with the Court of Federal Claims alone. You must also generally pay the full tax for the year before suing.
Pay First: the Flora Rule
A refund suit after IRS Letter 105C is a claim for money you have already paid. Under the Supreme Court's decision in Flora v. United States and its 1960 rehearing in Flora v. United States, the full tax assessed for the year must be paid before a refund suit can proceed. For most people who receive IRS Letter 105C, this is already satisfied, because they paid the original tax and are asking for part of it back. Nevertheless, if the IRS has also assessed additional tax for the same year, check that it is paid before you file.
Note also that the US Tax Court is not available here. The Tax Court hears disputes about proposed deficiencies, not refusals of refund claims. As a result, a disallowed claim goes to a district court or the Court of Federal Claims, both of which require full payment and usually a lawyer admitted to practise before them.
District Court Venue and the Living-Abroad Problem
The venue statute, 28 U.S.C. § 1402, says a refund suit against the United States in a district court may be brought only in the judicial district where the plaintiff resides. Courts have read that literally against taxpayers who live abroad. In the Topsnik litigation, for instance, the Ninth Circuit affirmed the dismissal of a German resident's refund suit for improper venue and described the Court of Federal Claims as the only court with both jurisdiction and venue. The opinion was unpublished, so it binds no one, but the reasoning follows the statute's plain words.
For a US citizen living in Britain who keeps a genuine home in, say, Connecticut, district court venue may still be available there. For someone who sold their last US property years ago, the safe working assumption is that the US Court of Federal Claims in Washington is the realistic forum. That court has nationwide jurisdiction over tax refund suits, so residence abroad does not block it.
Why the Forum Decides Some Cases Before They Start
Appeals from the Court of Federal Claims go to the Federal Circuit. Appeals from district courts go to the regional circuit for that district. That difference now matters for the NIIT credit argument. The Federal Circuit has ruled against it, so the Court of Federal Claims is bound to reject it. A district court in another circuit would not be bound, but an American with no US residence may have no district court to go to. In practice, therefore, the NIIT argument is closed for most UK residents, and fighting an IRS Letter 105C on that point alone rarely justifies the legal cost.
For an IRS Letter 105C that turns on facts, such as the timing and amount of UK tax, the forum matters far less. Those cases are usually won or lost on the documents, and most settle at Appeals once the evidence is clear. Where double tax remains after all of this, the treaty's mutual agreement procedure is a separate route, covered in our guide to competent authority relief under the US-UK treaty.
How TaxYork Can Help
We prepare US tax returns for Americans in Britain, including amended returns and refund claims built on UK tax that changed after an HMRC enquiry, a bonus clawback or a late HMRC repayment. When IRS Letter 105C or 106C arrives, we read the reason, check it against the correct limitation period, rebuild the Form 1116 or Form 2555 workings, and prepare the reply, the small case request or the formal protest.
After IRS Letter 105C, we also manage the calendar, which is where most refunds are really lost. That means diarising the section 6532 date, preparing Form 907 for signature in good time, and working alongside US litigation counsel where a suit becomes necessary. Where the claim sits within a wider compliance gap, such as missed US tax returns, a missed FBAR or unreported UK pension and investment accounts, we put the whole position in order through our FBAR and FATCA reporting service and US tax returns for expats, so that fixing one year does not expose another.
Conclusion
IRS Letter 105C is not the end of a refund claim, but it is the start of a deadline. From the mailing date you have two years to win the money back from the IRS or to sue, and a reply, a protest or an Appeals referral does not change that date. Only Form 907 signed by both sides, or a suit filed in time, keeps the claim alive.
For Americans in Britain who receive IRS Letter 105C, the details matter more than usual. Reviewers often apply the three-year rule to foreign tax credit claims that enjoy ten years. UK evidence needs translating into IRS terms. A district court may be closed to anyone with no US home, which leaves the Court of Federal Claims and the Federal Circuit's view of the law. Meanwhile, the August 2026 NIIT rulings mean protective claims on that point are best conceded, so that attention goes to the items that can still win.
If you have received IRS Letter 105C or 106C, note the date on the letter today, gather your HMRC documents, and decide quickly whether the refusal is a paperwork problem or a legal one.
Contact Us
If you have received a claim disallowance letter, or you are planning an amended return to recover US tax after a change in your UK position, contact us for a review before the clock runs down. You can also email hello@taxyork.com or call 020 3488 8606. We work with Americans, dual nationals and US business owners across Britain, and we will tell you plainly whether your claim is worth pursuing.
Disclaimer
This article gives general information about IRS claim disallowance letters, refund claims and related US and UK tax rules as they stood in November 2026. It is not tax or legal advice for your circumstances, and the case study uses invented people and illustrative figures only. Court decisions, IRS procedures and published guidance change, so take advice from a qualified professional before acting on anything in this article.
