Father with a leather bag beside a sealed IRS envelope in a London study after a CP87A notice arrives

A sealed IRS envelope on a London desk is often the first sign that a CP87A notice will make separated parents settle who claims the children.

Listen to this article

Prefer to listen? Press play — pick a voice below.

Introduction: Why a CP87A Notice Lands Differently on a Cross-Border Family

A CP87A notice is the IRS letter telling you that someone else filed a US return listing the same Social Security number for a dependent or qualifying child you claimed. For most domestic families, the notice signals a custody squabble. For an American parent in London whose former partner is British, however, the letter raises a sharper question: who else could possibly have filed?

At TaxYork, we see this letter arrive most often in the year after a separation, when two households file for the first time and nobody agreed who claims the children. The CP87A notice is short and calm. Nevertheless, the rules behind it reach into custody nights, boarding school terms, written releases and filing status, and the answer is rarely what either parent assumes.

What a CP87A Notice Actually Says

The CP87A notice lists the last four digits of each Social Security number that appeared on two returns for the same year. According to the IRS page explaining the CP87A notice, the agency has received another return claiming a dependent or qualifying child with the same number as one on yours. Importantly, the IRS will not tell you who the other filer is, because federal disclosure law forbids it.

The letter gives two paths. If you are entitled to the child, you need not send anything. If you are not, you correct your return on Form 1040-X. Consequently, the burden of judging entitlement on a CP87A notice sits with you. Most families judge it on the wrong test.

Why the Notice Is Not an Audit, Yet

The IRS states plainly that a CP87A notice is not an audit and asks for no documents at this stage. Instead, it is an invitation to self-correct before the agency decides which return to examine. In our experience, the IRS usually examines one or both returns when neither parent amends. That examination can take a year or more to resolve.

Therefore, treat the CP87A notice as a deadline in all but name. A considered response now costs far less than defending two returns, two filing statuses and possibly two years of credits later.

Who Else Could Have Claimed Your Child?

Every CP87A notice needs a second US filer. For a cross-border family, that fact alone narrows the field. Often, it also points to the real problem.

When the Other Parent Is British and Files Nothing

If your former spouse is a British national with no US filing obligation, they did not trigger your CP87A notice. That surprises many clients. Furthermore, the competing return came from someone who does file with the IRS. Typically, that is a dual-national former spouse, a US-based grandparent, an older child or a stranger using the number.

Dual nationals deserve particular attention. Many British parents discover their own US citizenship late, as accidental Americans, and file their first US returns during or after a divorce. Accordingly, a former spouse catching up on missed US tax returns may claim the children for the first time, without telling you, and both of you then receive the same CP87A notice.

Grandparents, Older Children and US-Based Relatives

Grandparents in the United States sometimes claim grandchildren they support financially, especially after paying school fees. However, the tie-breaker rules in section 152 of the Internal Revenue Code give a parent priority over a non-parent. A grandparent can claim only if no parent claims the child, and only where the grandparent's adjusted gross income is higher than that of any parent eligible to claim.

Older children create a quieter version of the problem. A student at a US university who files their own return and claims themselves will generate a CP87A notice on the parent's return. In that case, the fix usually sits with the child, who amends to show that someone else can claim them.

Identity Theft Against Children's Numbers

Children's Social Security numbers are valuable to fraudsters precisely because nobody monitors them. If no relative filed, the competing claim may be fraudulent. The IRS guidance on identity theft involving dependents explains how to report it and how to protect future years.

Once a CP87A notice points to fraud, request an Identity Protection PIN for yourself and, where available, for your children. Additionally, an IP PIN stops a fraudster from e-filing with that number again, which matters for parents abroad who learn of problems months late.

The Rules That Decide Who Wins a Duplicate Claim

When a CP87A notice arrives, most parents assume the court order decides who claims the child. In US tax law, neither does. Instead, the Treasury regulations count nights.

Custody Is Counted in Nights, Not Court Orders

Under Treasury Regulation 1.152-4, the custodial parent is the one with whom the child resides for the greater number of nights in the calendar year. A shared-parenting order that calls both parents "joint custodians" carries no weight. Similarly, a British child arrangements order that gives the father alternate weekends and half the holidays almost always makes the mother the custodial parent for IRS purposes.

There is one narrow exception. Where a parent works nights, the regulation counts days instead of nights for that parent. In our experience, this matters for surgeons, traders on Asian hours and aircrew, but rarely for anyone else.

Boarding School and Temporary Absences

Wealthy British families frequently send children to boarding school, and the night count then becomes contentious. The regulation treats a child who is temporarily absent as residing with the parent they would have stayed with but for the absence. Consequently, term-time nights at school count towards the parent whose home the child would otherwise have slept in.

In practice, that is usually the parent whose address the school holds as the main residence. Specifically, the regulation looks to the primary residence registered with the school on school days. Therefore, the address on the school's records can quietly decide a CP87A notice dispute worth thousands of dollars.

The Tie-Breaker and the FEIE Trap on AGI

Where the nights are exactly equal, the parent with the higher adjusted gross income is treated as custodial. Here a cross-border filer can lose without realising it. The Foreign Earned Income Exclusion on Form 2555 removes excluded salary from adjusted gross income altogether.

As a result, a London-based parent earning $250,000 who excludes $130,000 under the 2025 limit reports a lower AGI than a US-based former spouse earning $160,000. On an equal split, the lower-AGI parent loses the claim. Moreover, the same exclusion removes the refundable credit entirely, which we discuss below. For a parent on the foreign tax credit, by contrast, the full salary stays in AGI, and the tie-breaker usually falls their way.

Form 8332 and the Release That Divorce Decrees Cannot Replace

When parents agree that the non-custodial parent should claim the child, the agreement must be put in a specific written form. Otherwise, the custodial parent keeps the claim, whatever the settlement says. A CP87A notice then follows the first year both parents file.

What the Release Transfers and What It Never Can

IRS Form 8332 lets the custodial parent release the claim to the non-custodial parent for one year, several years or all future years. The regulation is blunt: a court order, decree or separation agreement may not serve as the written declaration. Consequently, an English consent order that awards the children to the father for US tax purposes is not enough on its own.

The release transfers the dependency claim, the child tax credit and the credit for other dependents. However, it never transfers head of household status, the earned income credit or the child and dependent care credit. Those stay with the parent the child actually lives with, because they rest on residence rather than dependency.

The Non-Filing Custodial Parent Still Has to Sign

A frequent cross-border error runs as follows. The American parent is non-custodial, the British parent files no US return, and the American assumes nobody is competing for the claim. Nevertheless, the statute treats the child as the qualifying child of the custodial parent unless that parent signs a release. Without a signed Form 8332, the American parent fails the residency test, whether or not the British parent ever files.

In other words, an uncontested claim is not the same as a valid claim. If an exam later examines the return, the absence of a release disallows the child, with interest. Therefore, we ask British former spouses to sign Form 8332 each year, leaving the taxpayer identification field blank where they have no US number and noting their nonresident status.

Revoking a Release

A custodial parent who signed a multi-year release can revoke it. The regulation requires written notice to the other parent, and the revocation takes effect no earlier than the tax year beginning after the notice. Additionally, the revoking parent attaches a copy to each return on which they then claim the child.

This matters when a settlement is renegotiated or when the non-custodial parent stops paying maintenance. A revocation served in December 2026, for example, cannot take effect before the 2027 tax year.

What Is Actually at Stake for a High Earner

For many wealthy parents, the child tax credit has already phased out. Accordingly, the real value at stake in a CP87A notice lies elsewhere. It is often misjudged.

Head of Household Status

Head of household status gives a wider set of tax brackets and a larger standard deduction than single or married filing separately. For 2026, the head of household standard deduction is $24,150, compared with $16,100 for single filers, according to the IRS announcement of the 2026 inflation adjustments. The 35 per cent bracket also stretches much further for heads of household.

An American married to a nonresident alien has a useful route here. IRS Publication 501 treats you as unmarried for head of household purposes if your spouse was a nonresident alien at any time in the year and you do not elect to treat them as resident. Still, the child must live with you for more than half the year, so a CP87A notice that reveals you are not the custodial parent can unwind your filing status as well as the dependent.

Child Tax Credit Phase-Outs and the Social Security Number Rule

The child tax credit is $2,200 per qualifying child for 2025 and 2026, with up to $1,700 refundable. It phases out by $50 for each $1,000 of modified AGI above $400,000 on a joint return and $200,000 for everyone else. Therefore, a parent on married filing separately with $580,000 of income receives nothing at all.

Since 2025, the credit also requires a valid Social Security number for the child and for the claiming parent, or at least one spouse on a joint return. Children born in London to an American parent need a number obtained through the US Embassy's federal benefits unit before the credit can be claimed. Without one, the child can at most qualify for the $500 credit for other dependents.

The Foreign Earned Income Exclusion Bar on the Refundable Credit

The refundable part of the credit, calculated on Schedule 8812, is not available to anyone who files Form 2555. Consequently, the parent on the foreign tax credit can receive up to $1,700 per child in cash, while a parent using the exclusion cannot. This single rule often decides which parent should hold the claim.

The UK Side Follows Different Rules Entirely

British Child Benefit has nothing to do with the US dependency claim. The claimant is whoever HMRC accepted as responsible for the child, and the current Child Benefit rates are £27.05 a week for the eldest child in 2026-27. Meanwhile, the High Income Child Benefit Charge claws back 1 per cent for every £200 of adjusted net income above £60,000.

After separation, the charge falls on the claimant or on a new partner living with them, not on the former spouse. As a result, a father who claims the children on his US return can have no Child Benefit position at all in the UK, and that mismatch is perfectly lawful.

A Worked Case Study: Two Claims, One London Family

The figures below are illustrative but typical of the cases we handle. Daniel is a US citizen working for a bank in London. His wife, Claire, is a dual US-UK national who learned of her American citizenship in 2024. They separated in March 2025 and remained legally married at the year end.

The Facts Behind the Duplicate Claim

Their two children, both US citizens with Social Security numbers, spent 230 nights with Claire and 135 with Daniel in 2025. Daniel earned $580,000, of which $60,000 related to workdays in New York and was US-source income. He filed as head of household, claimed both children and used the foreign tax credit. Claire earned the equivalent of $91,000, filed her first US return as part of a catch-up, claimed head of household and claimed both children.

In October 2026, both received a CP87A notice for 2025. Daniel was certain he would win. His British solicitor had said the consent order gave him the children "for tax purposes". However, no Form 8332 existed, and the consent order could not serve as one.

Who Wins and What the Amendment Costs

On the night count, Claire is the custodial parent, so she keeps the children and head of household status. Daniel cannot file as head of household because the children did not live with him for more than half the year, and Claire is a US citizen, so the nonresident-spouse route is closed. He must amend to married filing separately.

We calculated Daniel's 2025 position both ways. As head of household, his tax before credits was about $162,540, and the US tax left after his foreign tax credit, attributable to the New York days, was roughly $16,815. As married filing separately, his tax before credits rose to about $170,804, and the residual US tax became roughly $17,669. The amendment therefore costs him about $854, plus interest from 15 April 2026.

The child tax credit made no difference to Daniel, because his income is far above the $200,000 phase-out for separate filers. The difference is also too small for the substantial understatement penalty, which needs an understatement above $5,000 or 10 per cent of the correct tax. Furthermore, Daniel can usually recover the extra US tax through a higher UK credit on his New York workdays, so long as he amends his UK return within the four-year window.

What the Release Calculation Shows

The more valuable question is who should hold the claim in future. If Claire released the children to Daniel on Form 8332, Daniel would gain nothing, because his credit is fully phased out. Claire, by contrast, uses the foreign tax credit rather than the exclusion, so she can claim the refundable credit. At 15 per cent of her earned income above $2,500, her cap is far above the $3,400 maximum for two children.

Accordingly, the family should keep the claim with Claire every year. Moreover, they should document that in a signed letter. That way, no second CP87A notice follows. In our experience, framing the decision as "which household gains cash" rather than "who has rights" settles most disputes within a week.

Responding to a CP87A Notice Step by Step

A good response to a CP87A notice follows a fixed sequence. In our practice, we work through it in the same order every time, and we recommend you do the same.

Before You Contact Anyone

First, compare the four digits on the CP87A notice with each child's Social Security card. A mistyped number explains a surprising share of these letters, and the IRS says you simply use the correct number next year. Next, count the nights for the year from calendars, school records and travel bookings, and treat boarding school nights under the temporary absence rule.

After that, check whether a signed Form 8332 exists for the year and whether anyone revoked it. Finally, consider who else files a US return that could include your child. If the answer is nobody, start the identity theft route immediately rather than waiting.

Amending With Form 1040-X From Abroad

If the CP87A notice shows you were not entitled, file Form 1040-X to remove the child and any linked credits and, where necessary, change your filing status. Electronic filing of amended returns works from abroad through professional software. Otherwise, a paper 1040-X goes to the international address in the instructions, and post from the UK can add weeks.

Pay the extra tax and interest with the amendment if you can. Interest runs from the original due date of 15 April, even though Americans abroad have an automatic extension to 15 June for filing. Similarly, if a refund was paid on the original return, the amendment needs to show the repayment clearly.

If Neither Parent Withdraws

When both parents stand firm, the IRS will normally examine one or both returns and ask each side for proof of residence and relationship. A London parent then needs evidence an American examiner will accept: school letters, GP registration, council tax bills and a calendar of nights. In addition, translation of solicitor-speak matters, because examiners do not read English consent orders the way family lawyers do.

If the IRS disallows a child tax credit because of reckless or intentional disregard of the rules, it can ban the credit for two years, or ten years for fraud. Recovering it afterwards requires Form 8862. For stalled cases, the Taxpayer Advocate Service can help when the IRS does not respond within its normal timeframes.

When a CP87A Notice Exposes a Wider Compliance Gap

The CP87A notice itself concerns one line on one return. In our experience, however, the examination that follows a contested claim is rarely confined to that line, and this is where wealthy families take real risk.

Missed FBARs and Missed Reporting Surface in Examinations

An examiner checking residence asks where the children live and how the household is funded. Those questions lead naturally to UK bank accounts, ISAs and pensions. If you have a missed FBAR or missed reporting on a UK pension or investment account, a dependency examination is the worst place for it to emerge.

Therefore, before you send any documents, confirm that every year is clean. The FBAR and FATCA reporting position for each open year should reconcile with the bank statements you might show an examiner. Where it does not, voluntary correction before contact is far stronger than explanation after it.

Divorce Changes the Whole Return, Not Just the Children

Separation alters more than dependants. Asset transfers, maintenance, the family home and pension sharing orders all carry US consequences. Our guide to US-UK divorce tax consequences for high-net-worth couples covers those issues, and they often explain why two first-year returns after a split conflict.

Similarly, a CP87A notice sometimes arrives alongside other letters. If the IRS has already applied a refund to a balance on another year, our article on the CP49 notice for Americans in Britain explains how offsets work. Children with investment income raise a separate issue. It is covered in our guide to the kiddie tax for US-British children.

Treaty Credits Must Follow the Amendment

Any change to US tax on income that the UK also taxes affects the credit position on both sides. The US-UK tax treaty and foreign tax credit planning work therefore needs revisiting whenever a dependency amendment changes the US liability. Daniel's $854 is small, but the same mismatch on larger US-source income can run into five figures.

How TaxYork Can Help

We prepare US and UK returns for American families in Britain, including parents in the first years after a separation. When a CP87A notice arrives, we count the nights properly, read the consent order against the Treasury regulations and model each parent's position under every filing status. Furthermore, we prepare Form 8332 releases and revocations so that the claim sits with the household that gains most.

Where a contested claim threatens an examination, we review every open year first. That includes FBARs, Form 8938, UK pensions and ISAs, so nothing surprising reaches an examiner. Our work is comprehensive tax preparation and compliance, delivered by a team that handles US-UK families every day.

Conclusion

A CP87A notice looks routine, yet for a cross-border family it tests rules most parents have never read. Nights decide custody, boarding school terms count towards the home the child would otherwise sleep in, and a British consent order cannot replace Form 8332. Moreover, a non-custodial American parent needs a signed release even when the British parent files nothing.

For high earners, the credit has usually phased out, so the real stakes are head of household status, refundable credits on the other side of the family and, above all, the examination that follows an unresolved claim. Therefore, answer the CP87A notice promptly, amend where the rules say you must, and agree the claim in writing for future years.

Contact Us

If you or your former partner has received a CP87A notice, or you want next year's claim settled before either of you files, please book a consultation with our team. You can also email hello@taxyork.com or call 020 3488 8606. We will review the notice, your night count and your wider US filing position, and we will tell you exactly what each return should show.

Disclaimer

This article provides general information about US and UK tax rules as they stand in November 2026 and does not constitute tax, legal or financial advice. Dependency, filing status and credit outcomes depend on the exact facts of each family, including custody nights, written releases and each parent's income. The case study is illustrative, and its figures are rounded. Please obtain advice tailored to your circumstances before acting. TaxYork accepts no liability for actions taken on the basis of this article without a formal engagement.

Frequently Asked Questions

A CP87A notice means the IRS received another US return claiming a dependent or qualifying child with the same Social Security number as one on your return. It is not an audit and asks for no documents. If you are entitled to the child, you need not reply; if you are not, you should file Form 1040-X to correct your return.

No. The IRS says that if you are entitled to claim the dependent, you do not need to send anything. However, keep evidence of the nights the child lived with you, school records and any signed Form 8332. If the other filer does not amend, the IRS may examine both returns and ask for that proof.

The parent with whom the child lived for more nights in the calendar year wins, unless that parent signed Form 8332 releasing the claim. If nights are exactly equal, the parent with the higher adjusted gross income wins. A parent always beats a grandparent or other relative under the section 152 tie-breaker rules.

Only if the child lived with you for more nights, or the British parent signs Form 8332. A non-filing custodial parent still holds the claim under US law, so a non-custodial American parent needs a signed release. In practice, the British parent can sign without a US taxpayer number by noting their nonresident status.

No. Treasury Regulation 1.152-4 states that a court order, decree or separation agreement cannot serve as the written declaration. The custodial parent must sign Form 8332 or an equivalent unconditional statement naming you and the tax years covered. English consent orders are treated exactly the same way.

Yes, if you are the custodial parent. Head of household depends on the child living with you for more than half the year and on you paying over half the cost of the home. Releasing the dependency claim on Form 8332 does not transfer head of household status, which always stays with the custodial parent.

If you or the other filer amends, a CP87A notice usually closes within a few months of the amended return being processed. If neither side amends, the IRS normally examines one or both returns, and that can take a year or more. Paper amendments posted from the UK add further weeks to the timeline.

Yes, if you use the foreign tax credit rather than the Foreign Earned Income Exclusion. Anyone filing Form 2555 cannot claim the refundable portion, which is up to $1,700 per child for 2025 and 2026. You and the child also need valid Social Security numbers, and income phase-outs apply above $200,000 or $400,000 jointly.

Get in Touch

Ready to get
your US taxes
sorted?

Whether you need help with IRS Streamlined filings, annual US tax returns, or cross-border tax planning — our team is here for you.

View Contact Details

Send us a message