Empty courtroom jury seats behind a legal file and pen, illustrating the FBAR penalty jury trial question

Whether a jury must hear a wilful FBAR penalty before the IRS can collect it is the question the Sagoo remand has reopened.

Listen to this article

Prefer to listen? Press play — pick a voice below.

Introduction: The FBAR Penalty Jury Trial Question After Sagoo

The FBAR penalty jury trial argument asks whether the IRS can lawfully assess a wilful FBAR penalty itself, or whether the Seventh Amendment requires a jury to decide the case first. A Texas federal court said yes to a jury in September 2025 and threw out a $1,020,923 penalty. In October 2026 the Fifth Circuit sent that case, United States v. Sagoo, back for a fresh look, so the answer is open again.

For an American living in London with a proposed wilful penalty on the desk, that uncertainty is not academic. It shapes whether you sign a statute extension, whether an FBAR penalty jury trial is worth waiting for, whether you pay, where the Justice Department is likely to sue you and what you put in your answer when it does. The FBAR penalty jury trial defence is real, but it is narrower and more fragile than the September 2025 headlines suggested.

At TaxYork, we prepare US and UK returns and FBARs for executives, founders and investors who live in Britain, and we see the moment a penalty letter arrives. This guide sets out what Sagoo decided, why the Supreme Court's June 2026 ruling in FCC v. AT&T undercut it, what the remand will turn on, and the practical choices a UK resident faces at each stage of a wilful penalty case.

Why the FBAR Penalty Jury Trial Debate Matters to UK Residents

The FBAR penalty jury trial debate matters more to Americans in Britain than to most filers, because the people who end up with wilful penalties are disproportionately long-term expats with sizeable UK accounts. Many held ISAs, pensions and sterling savings for decades without realising the US wanted a report on each one.

Furthermore, a UK resident has fewer natural defences once the IRS has assessed. You cannot easily attend meetings in Washington, and US-situs assets such as a brokerage account or a future US Social Security pension become the obvious targets. Consequently, any rule that stops the IRS acting before a jury has heard the case carries real weight for you.

What Happened in United States v. Sagoo?

Sagoo is a federal suit in which the government asked a Texas court to turn a wilful FBAR penalty of $1,020,923 into a judgment. The district court dismissed the suit in September 2025 on Seventh Amendment grounds, the government appealed, and in October 2026 the Fifth Circuit vacated the dismissal and remanded for reconsideration.

The Facts the Court Worked From

According to the Journal of Accountancy's summary of the ruling, Sharnjeet Sagoo was a US person with accounts in Kenya, India and England for 2011, 2012 and 2013. Her year-end balances were $1,445,188, $1,503,358 and $1,769,355. The IRS assessed the wilful penalty on 2 December 2020, she did not pay, and the government later accepted that its calculation might need correcting.

The case number is 4:24-cv-01159 in the Northern District of Texas, and the district court's order dismissing the suit is dated 19 September 2025. Notably, the government did not argue that the jury right was irrelevant. It argued instead that a jury was available later, once it sued to collect.

Why the District Court Dismissed With Prejudice

The court accepted the FBAR penalty jury trial argument and rejected the government's "you get your jury later" position. It reasoned that the IRS had acted as investigator, decision-maker and enforcer at the assessment stage. In addition, assessment triggered real consequences, including administrative offsets, long before any jury could sit. A trial that arrives only after those consequences, the court said, does not honour the right.

Importantly, the judge relied heavily on the Fifth Circuit's own 2025 decision in the AT&T forfeiture case. That reliance is exactly what later unravelled.

The Appeal and the October 2026 Remand

The government appealed in late 2025 under Fifth Circuit docket 25-11271. After the Supreme Court took the AT&T case, the appeal was effectively paused. Commentators report that in October 2026 the Fifth Circuit vacated the dismissal and returned the case to the trial judge. The remand order does not decide whether Sagoo wins. It simply tells the district court to start again under the Supreme Court's new framework. Until that happens, no court anywhere is bound by an FBAR penalty jury trial ruling in the taxpayer's favour.

Why Did FCC v. AT&T Change the FBAR Penalty Jury Trial Analysis?

FCC v. AT&T, decided on 4 June 2026 by an 8-1 vote, held that the FCC's forfeiture orders did not breach the Seventh Amendment because they are not binding. The carrier owes nothing until the government wins a fresh trial in federal court. Because Sagoo leaned on the reversed Fifth Circuit ruling, its foundation fell away.

What Jarkesy Decided in 2024

The starting point is SEC v. Jarkesy, decided on 27 June 2024. The Supreme Court held that when an agency seeks civil penalties that resemble a common-law fraud claim, the Seventh Amendment entitles the defendant to a jury, and the agency cannot route the case through its own in-house tribunal instead. Jarkesy did not mention FBARs, but practitioners immediately asked whether an IRS assessment of a wilful penalty was the same kind of in-house decision. That question sits at the root of every FBAR penalty jury trial challenge since.

What the Supreme Court Said About Non-Binding Orders

In FCC v. AT&T, Chief Justice Roberts wrote for the majority. Specifically, the Court looked at the whole statutory scheme. An FCC forfeiture order is a demand, not a judgment, and if the carrier refuses to pay, the Justice Department must sue and prove its case before a jury. Therefore, the agency's findings never conclusively fix the carrier's liability, and no jury right is lost at the agency stage.

The Court also rejected the argument that making a party wait for the government to sue placed an unconstitutional burden on its jury right. Accordingly, the "jury gets the last word" structure is enough, at least where nothing happens to the party before that last word.

Where the FBAR Regime Looks Different

This is where the remand will be fought. Under 31 U.S.C. 5321, the IRS assesses the FBAR penalty itself and then has two years to sue. Unlike an unpaid FCC forfeiture, an assessed FBAR penalty is treated as a debt owed to the United States from day one. Interest runs, a late-payment charge builds, and the debt can be referred for collection and offset against federal payments.

As a result, Sagoo's lawyers can argue that the FBAR assessment is not a mere demand. It changes the taxpayer's position before any jury hears the evidence. The government's answer is that a full de novo trial still follows, and that it may also invoke the "public rights" exception that Jarkesy left in place. In our view, the FBAR penalty jury trial argument has survived AT&T in weakened form, but it has not been killed.

How Does an Assessed FBAR Penalty Hurt You Before Any Trial?

Once the IRS assesses a wilful FBAR penalty, it becomes a non-tax debt to the federal government. After 90 days it attracts a late-payment charge of up to 6% a year, and after 180 days it can go to Treasury for collection and offset. None of this waits for a court.

Interest, the 6% Charge and Collection Costs

31 U.S.C. 3717 sets the add-ons. Interest accrues at the Treasury rate, administrative costs are charged, and a penalty charge of up to 6% a year applies to any part of the debt more than 90 days past due. On a $1 million penalty, the 6% charge alone can add $60,000 a year. Consequently, a taxpayer who refuses to pay while waiting for a possible FBAR penalty jury trial is betting that the final judgment will wipe out those add-ons as well.

Offsets Against Federal Payments

The Treasury Offset Program lets the government take federal payments to pay delinquent debts. For an American in Britain, the realistic targets are US federal tax refunds and, later in life, US Social Security. Under 31 U.S.C. 3716, the first $9,000 of federal benefit payments in a 12-month period is protected, and Treasury regulations cap Social Security offsets at 15% of each payment. Even so, a retired London-based American with a decent US pension could see part of it taken for years, whatever the eventual outcome of any FBAR penalty jury trial.

What an FBAR Penalty Does Not Trigger

Some fears are misplaced. Because the FBAR penalty arises under Title 31 rather than the Internal Revenue Code, it is not a "seriously delinquent tax debt" under 26 U.S.C. 7345, so it does not on its own put your US passport at risk. Likewise, it is not an income tax lien in the usual sense. Nevertheless, the government can still sue, win a judgment and enforce it against any US assets you hold.

Where Can the Government Sue an American Living in Britain?

The Justice Department can generally sue a defendant who does not live in the United States in any federal district. That venue rule matters, because whether you can raise a strong FBAR penalty jury trial defence, or an excessive fines defence, now depends heavily on which circuit hears the case.

The Venue Rule for Non-Residents

Under 28 U.S.C. 1391(c)(3), a defendant not resident in the United States may be sued in any judicial district. For a UK resident, that means the government chooses the court, and with it the precedent that governs any FBAR penalty jury trial. In practice it tends to sue where it has staff and familiar precedent, but the statute does not force it to pick your old home state.

Why the Circuit Changes Your Defences

The Fifth Circuit covers Texas, Louisiana and Mississippi, and the Sagoo remand will produce the first post-AT&T ruling on the jury question there. Meanwhile, the excessive fines picture is split. The Eleventh Circuit treats wilful FBAR penalties as fines and reviews them account by account, while the First Circuit has said they are not fines at all. The Fourth Circuit, in the Rund opinion of September 2026, assumed the Eighth Amendment applied but still upheld about $2.92 million. We covered that ruling in our guide to FBAR penalties and the Excessive Fines Clause.

What the UK Will and Will Not Do

English courts have long refused to enforce foreign revenue and penal claims directly, and the US-UK tax treaty does not cover a Title 31 penalty. In practice, therefore, the US collects from US-based assets and payments rather than through a UK court. That is not a reason to ignore a penalty. A US judgment lasts for years, can be renewed, and follows you the moment you open a US account, inherit US property or move back.

Which Stage of an FBAR Penalty Case Are You In?

Your options depend on whether the penalty is still proposed, has been assessed but not sued on, or is already in litigation. The FBAR penalty jury trial argument is weakest before assessment, because nothing binding has happened yet, and strongest once you are a defendant who can formally demand a jury.

Before Assessment: Letter 3709 and Appeals

A proposed penalty usually arrives with Letter 3709 and a 30-day window to agree or protest. The IRS's FBAR penalty publication, Pub 5970, explains that Appeals will generally consider the case before assessment only if enough time remains on the six-year assessment period, which is why examiners often ask you to sign an extension on Form 15616. Furthermore, the Internal Revenue Manual's FBAR penalty chapter generally limits the total wilful penalty across all open years to 50% of the highest aggregate balance, and examiners have discretion to go lower.

Our separate guide on the six-year FBAR statute of limitations explains how those years are counted. Signing an extension is often sensible, because it buys an Appeals hearing with full settlement authority. However, it also gives the government more time, so it should be a deliberate choice rather than a reflex.

After Assessment: The Two-Year Window

Once the IRS assesses, normally by Letter 3708, the government has two years to sue under 31 U.S.C. 5321(b)(2). During that window, the debt is live, the 6% charge is running and offsets can begin. You might pay to stop the add-ons, but paying and then suing for a refund usually means a claim against the United States, and such claims are generally heard without a jury. Paying therefore tends to give up the FBAR penalty jury trial route in exchange for certainty.

In Litigation: Making the Jury Demand

If the government sues, the jury does not appear automatically. Under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 38, you must serve a written jury demand no later than 14 days after the last pleading directed to the issue, or the right is waived. Your answer should also plead the Seventh Amendment defence, the excessive fines defence and any procedural points, such as missing supervisory approval, which we discussed in our guide to section 6751(b) penalty approval. An FBAR penalty jury trial defence that is not pleaded early is very hard to revive later.

What Must the Government Prove at an FBAR Penalty Jury Trial?

Whatever happens on the constitutional question, a defendant who reaches trial puts the government to its proof on wilfulness. Most courts treat wilfulness as including reckless disregard, and most apply the ordinary civil standard of proof. At an FBAR penalty jury trial, twelve citizens rather than a judge then decide whether your conduct crossed that line.

Wilfulness Includes Recklessness

The penalty in 31 U.S.C. 5321 can reach the greater of a statutory amount, currently $165,353 under the FinCEN inflation table in 31 CFR 1010.821, or 50% of the account balance at the time of the violation. Courts have repeatedly held that wilfulness covers recklessness, such as ticking "no" to the foreign accounts question on Schedule B, or never telling your preparer that the accounts existed. By contrast, a genuine misunderstanding by someone who always told their adviser everything is far harder to label wilful.

Why a Jury May See It Differently

Judges have decided many wilful cases on summary judgment, often on the strength of Schedule B answers, so few cases have ever reached an FBAR penalty jury trial. A jury is a different audience. Twelve people may find it plausible that a dual national who moved to London as a child, and who never had a US account, did not grasp that a sterling ISA was "foreign". That is why defence lawyers value the FBAR penalty jury trial route even where the constitutional argument fails: a demand under Rule 38 can still put the factual question of wilfulness before a jury in the government's collection suit.

The Evidence Juries Respond To

In our experience, the files that persuade at an FBAR penalty jury trial are contemporaneous. Emails to a previous preparer, UK tax returns showing every account declared to HMRC, and bank records showing no attempt to hide funds all count. Equally, evidence that money was moved into nominee names or cashed out after a bank letter will be damaging. The IRS FBAR reference page and the FinCEN filing guidance set the rules a jury will be told about.

Case Study: A Proposed Wilful Penalty for a London Fund Manager

The following illustration uses invented but realistic figures. It shows how the FBAR penalty jury trial question changes the cost of each decision for a UK resident, and why the timing of each step matters.

The Facts and the Proposed Penalty

Elena is a US citizen who has lived in London since 2004 and works as a portfolio manager. She filed US returns but no FBARs for 2020 to 2023, and her Schedule B answered "no" to the foreign accounts question. Her accounts were a sterling current account, a UK investment account and a stocks and shares ISA. Their combined high balance peaked in 2022 at $2,400,000, with the investment account alone at $1,700,000.

In October 2026 she receives Letter 3709 proposing wilful penalties. Following the IRM cap, the examiner proposes $1,200,000 in total, which is 50% of the highest aggregate balance, spread across the four years by balance. Because the 2020 FBAR year closes on 15 April 2027, the examiner also asks her to sign Form 15616.

The Three Paths in Numbers

If Elena signs the extension and goes to Appeals, she keeps every argument, including a later FBAR penalty jury trial, and pays nothing yet. A settlement that recharacterises the case as non-wilful would cap the exposure at one inflation-adjusted non-wilful penalty per year under the Supreme Court's Bittner decision, or about $66,144 at the current $16,536 figure for four years.

If she refuses to sign, the IRS will probably assess $1,200,000 before April 2027. From then on, the 6% charge could add $72,000 a year, plus interest. If she pays to stop that clock and sues for a refund, she trades the jury for a bench trial. Alternatively, if she does not pay and the government sues in, say, Texas, she can demand an FBAR penalty jury trial, plead the Sagoo argument and challenge wilfulness before a jury.

What We Would Recommend Here

On these facts, we would usually sign the extension and build the non-wilful case for Appeals first. Elena declared every account to HMRC, her UK returns are clean, and her Schedule B error was made by a US preparer who never asked. That is a strong factual story for Appeals and, if needed, for a jury. The FBAR penalty jury trial argument stays in reserve for litigation rather than driving her decisions now.

Common Mistakes With FBAR Penalties and What to Do Next

The commonest mistakes are acting on headlines, letting deadlines pass and assuming the problem stays in America. Each of them can turn a negotiable penalty into a judgment.

Treating Sagoo as Settled Law

Several commentaries from late 2025 described Sagoo as a defence that ended FBAR assessments. It never bound anyone outside that case, and the October 2026 remand removed even that result. Accordingly, nobody should refuse to engage with an examiner on the assumption that an FBAR penalty jury trial argument will make the penalty disappear.

Missing the Protest or Jury Deadlines

The 30-day protest period, the six-year assessment window, the two-year suit period and the 14-day jury demand under Rule 38 each close quietly. Missing any one of them can cost an argument permanently, and missing the last one forfeits an FBAR penalty jury trial altogether. Moreover, the IRS withdrew its delinquent FBAR procedures in July 2026, as we explained in our note on the end of the delinquent FBAR submission procedures, so late filers now have fewer soft landings.

Filing Late FBARs Without a Strategy

If you have missed FBARs but have not been contacted, the right move is usually to bring your US tax returns and FBARs up to date through a considered disclosure route, with a written account of why the reports were missed. Quietly filing six years of FBARs without amending the returns that answered "no" can look worse than the original failure.

How TaxYork Can Help

TaxYork prepares US federal returns, FBARs, Forms 8938, 5471 and 8621, and the matching UK Self Assessment for high-net-worth Americans in Britain. When a client faces a proposed FBAR penalty, we rebuild the account history year by year, reconcile the balances to HMRC filings, and prepare the factual record that Appeals or a litigation team needs.

We work alongside your US litigation counsel where a case is heading to court, supplying the account schedules, exchange-rate workings and penalty computations that frame any FBAR penalty jury trial. For clients who have not yet been contacted, we focus on bringing missed FBARs and returns into compliance before an examiner arrives.

Conclusion

The FBAR penalty jury trial argument is alive but unsettled. Sagoo showed a court willing to strike down a wilful assessment, while FCC v. AT&T showed the Supreme Court willing to accept agency penalties that only become binding after a trial. The FBAR regime sits between those two positions, because an assessment starts interest, charges and offsets before any jury sits.

For Americans in Britain, the practical lesson is to treat the FBAR penalty jury trial argument as one tool among several. Protect your deadlines, build the factual case against wilfulness, think carefully before signing or refusing a statute extension, and plead every defence early if the Justice Department sues.

Contact Us

If you have received Letter 3709, Letter 3708 or a demand for payment on an FBAR penalty, or you suspect you have missed FBARs for UK accounts, please contact us for a confidential review. You can also reach the TaxYork team at hello@taxyork.com or on 020 3488 8606.

Disclaimer

This article gives general information on FBAR penalties and the Seventh Amendment as at 19 November 2026, including litigation that is still in progress. It is not legal, tax or financial advice for your circumstances, and the case study is an illustration rather than a real client. TaxYork prepares tax returns and compliance filings and does not act as litigation counsel, so anyone facing a penalty suit should also take advice from a US attorney. Rules, case law and penalty figures can change, so please check the current position before acting.

Frequently Asked Questions

Yes, if the government sues to collect, a defendant can demand a jury on liability and wilfulness under Rule 38. The open question after Sagoo is whether the IRS may assess the penalty before that trial. The FBAR penalty jury trial argument says it may not, but courts have not settled it.

A Texas federal court dismissed a $1,020,923 wilful FBAR penalty suit in September 2025, holding that IRS assessment without a jury breached the Seventh Amendment. The ruling relied on a Fifth Circuit AT&T decision the Supreme Court later reversed, and in October 2026 the Fifth Circuit vacated and remanded.

Yes, under current law. Section 5321 lets the IRS assess the penalty administratively, then gives the government two years to sue if you do not pay. Whether that assessment step is constitutional for wilful penalties is the issue now back before the Texas court in Sagoo.

The IRS has six years from the FBAR due date to assess a penalty, whether or not a late FBAR was filed. After assessment, the government has two more years to bring a collection suit. Signing Form 15616 extends the assessment period, usually in exchange for an Appeals hearing.

The US mainly collects from US-based assets and payments, such as tax refunds, Social Security and US accounts, rather than through English courts, which do not enforce foreign revenue or penal claims. A US judgment can still last for many years and becomes enforceable whenever you hold US assets.

For each violation, the maximum is the greater of $165,353, the inflation-adjusted figure applying since January 2025, or 50% of the account balance at the time of the violation. IRS guidance generally limits the total across all open years to 50% of the highest aggregate balance.

Not on its own. Passport certification under section 7345 applies to seriously delinquent tax debts under the Internal Revenue Code, and FBAR penalties arise under Title 31 instead. However, the debt can still be offset against federal payments and enforced through a court judgment.

Paying stops interest and the 6% late-payment charge, but a refund claim is a suit against the United States, which is generally heard without a jury. Paying therefore tends to give up the FBAR penalty jury trial route. The right choice depends on the strength of your wilfulness defence.

Get in Touch

Ready to get
your US taxes
sorted?

Whether you need help with IRS Streamlined filings, annual US tax returns, or cross-border tax planning — our team is here for you.

View Contact Details

Send us a message