Introduction: FBAR Excessive Fines and Why the Rund Ruling Matters Now
FBAR excessive fines is the constitutional argument that a wilful penalty for unreported foreign accounts can be so large that it breaches the Eighth Amendment's ban on excessive fines. On 4 September 2026 the Fourth Circuit tested that argument in United States v. Rund and upheld a penalty of roughly $2.9 million. For an American in London with a decade of unreported UK accounts, the ruling on FBAR excessive fines is a warning rather than a lifeline.
At TaxYork, we prepare US returns and FBARs for senior bankers, company owners and investors who discovered their reporting gap late. Many have read that FBAR excessive fines rulings mean the courts are now "cutting" penalties. However, that headline misreads what the courts have done. This article explains what Rund decided, where the law is split, which court would hear your case, and why the cheapest defence is still the one you use before the IRS ever writes to you.
What the FBAR Excessive Fines Argument Actually Says
The Eighth Amendment to the US Constitution says excessive fines shall not be imposed. In United States v. Bajakajian, the Supreme Court held that a fine breaches that rule when it is "grossly disproportional" to the gravity of the offence. Consequently, the FBAR excessive fines defence asks a court to compare the penalty with the harm the missing report caused.
Two questions sit inside every FBAR excessive fines challenge. First, is a civil FBAR penalty a "fine" at all, or a remedial charge outside the Eighth Amendment? Second, if it is a fine, is this particular penalty grossly out of proportion? Rund answered only the second question, and that choice matters.
Why Americans in Britain Should Care
Americans living in the UK hold exactly the accounts that generate large penalties. A stocks and shares ISA, a Barclays current account, a SIPP, a Swiss account from an earlier posting and a joint account with a British spouse can each be reportable. Furthermore, UK banks report US account holders to HMRC under FATCA, and HMRC passes that data to the IRS. Therefore, the IRS often knows about the accounts before the taxpayer files anything, which is why an FBAR excessive fines argument usually arises only after an assessment. The IRS FBAR guidance page sets out who must file, and Investopedia's FBAR explainer gives a plain-English overview.
What the Fourth Circuit Decided in United States v. Rund
Richard Rund was a US citizen and businessman with more than a dozen accounts in Hong Kong, Switzerland and China. The IRS identified 48 reporting deficiencies across 2003 to 2008, 2013 and 2014. It then assessed about $2.92 million in wilful penalties, and the government sued to collect. You can read the Fourth Circuit's published Rund opinion in full.
The Accounts and the Missed Reports
Rund's facts were not sympathetic. He held business accounts through a company where a friend acted as nominee shareholder, and he opened a Swiss account in the name of a Mauritius company "for US tax reasons". Moreover, he entered the Offshore Voluntary Disclosure Program in 2010, opened two new Chinese accounts while still inside it, left them off his 2013 FBAR, and was removed from the programme in 2016. He later filed some late FBARs, but even those omitted accounts.
Wilfulness: Recklessness Is Enough
The court held that his failures were wilful as a matter of law, without a trial. Under the Fourth Circuit's earlier Horowitz decision, wilfulness includes objective recklessness. That means you clearly ought to have known there was a grave risk an accurate FBAR was not being filed, and you could have found out very easily. In particular, the court relied on tax returns where Rund answered "no" to the foreign account question on Schedule B. It also noted that he never told his preparers about the accounts.
Rund argued that ADHD, cancer treatment and long business litigation explained his lapses. However, the court observed that he filed complete FBARs for 2009 to 2012 despite the same conditions. Accordingly, personal hardship did not defeat recklessness, and the court moved on to the FBAR excessive fines question.
The $2.9 Million Penalty Survives the Eighth Amendment
On the constitutional point, the court assumed without deciding that the Excessive Fines Clause applies to civil FBAR penalties. It then found the penalty was not grossly disproportional. The statutory maximum for Rund's violations was $9,842,840, so the assessment was only about 30 per cent of the ceiling. Spread across the accounts and years, it came to roughly 14 to 16 per cent of each balance. Additionally, the court stressed that the violations were repeated over eight years and went hand in hand with unreported income. Those two facts, repetition and lost tax, are what sank Rund's FBAR excessive fines defence.
The Three-Way Circuit Split on FBAR Excessive Fines
The federal appeals courts now take three different positions on FBAR excessive fines. That disagreement makes geography, rather than law, a major factor in your risk.
Toth: Not a Fine at All
In 2022, the First Circuit held in United States v. Toth that a civil FBAR penalty is remedial and not a fine. On that view, the Eighth Amendment simply does not apply, however large the penalty. The Supreme Court declined to hear Toth's appeal in 2023, although Justice Gorsuch dissented from that refusal.
Schwarzbaum: A Fine, Judged Account by Account
In contrast, the Eleventh Circuit held in United States v. Schwarzbaum that FBAR penalties are at least partly punitive, so the clause applies. Crucially, it said the analysis must run account by account and year by year. Using that method, it struck out $300,000 of penalties on one small account whose balance never exceeded about $16,000, because the $100,000 statutory minimum dwarfed it. The Journal of Accountancy summary of Schwarzbaum records that the remaining $12 million or so was upheld.
Rund and the Pending Jouppi Case
The Fourth Circuit sat between those positions. It left open both whether the clause applies and whether the test runs account by account, because Rund argued only about his total penalty. Meanwhile, on 20 July 2026 the Supreme Court agreed to hear Jouppi v. Alaska. That case asks whether courts judge an offence's gravity in the abstract or by the defendant's own conduct. A ruling, expected in the 2026-27 term, will shape every future FBAR excessive fines argument, even though Jouppi concerns an aircraft forfeiture.
Where an American Abroad Gets Sued: The Venue Problem
No competitor analysis we have read addresses the question that matters most to an American living in London. If the IRS assesses a wilful penalty and you do not pay, which court hears your FBAR excessive fines defence?
No US Home Means Any District
The IRS cannot collect an FBAR penalty by itself through the Tax Court. Instead, the Justice Department must sue in a federal district court within two years of assessment under 31 U.S.C. § 5321. For a defendant who is not resident in the United States, 28 U.S.C. § 1391(c)(3) allows the suit in any judicial district. As a result, the government has wide latitude over where an expat's case is heard.
In practice, a suit filed in the First Circuit faces Toth, where the clause gives no protection. Conversely, a suit filed in Florida, Georgia or Alabama faces Schwarzbaum and its account-by-account review. Therefore, an American in Britain cannot count on the more generous FBAR excessive fines rule, because the choice of forum largely belongs to the government.
Collection Suit Versus Refund Suit
Alternatively, a taxpayer can pay the penalty and sue for a refund, either in a district court or in the Court of Federal Claims. Because the FBAR penalty arises under Title 31 rather than the Internal Revenue Code, Tax Court remedies are unavailable. That route lets you pick the forum, but it requires paying first and then litigating for years. Consequently, for most of our clients the forum question is a reason to avoid an assessment, not a strategy to win after one.
When the FBAR Excessive Fines Defence Can Work, and When It Cannot
The FBAR excessive fines argument is narrow. It is strongest where the penalty is fixed by the statutory minimum and weakest where the IRS has already scaled the penalty to the balances.
The Small-Account Floor Problem
The wilful penalty is the greater of a fixed amount or 50 per cent of the account balance at the time of the violation. After inflation adjustment under 31 C.F.R. § 1010.821, that fixed amount is $165,353 for penalties assessed on or after 17 January 2025. The non-wilful maximum is $16,536. No later adjustment had been published when we checked in 2026. So a wilful penalty on a £10,000 cash ISA can be more than ten times the account. That is the Schwarzbaum pattern, and it is where an FBAR excessive fines objection has real force.
Why the IRS Mitigation Method Defeats Most Challenges
Since 2015, IRS examiners have generally capped the total wilful penalty at 50 per cent of the highest aggregate balance across all years. The Internal Revenue Manual FBAR penalty chapter sets out the related mitigation rules. That is exactly what happened to Rund, and it produced an effective rate of about 14 per cent per account-year. Because the IRS has already moderated the figure, a court is unlikely to call it grossly disproportional. In short, the more reasonable the IRS calculation looks, the weaker the FBAR excessive fines defence becomes.
Bittner Changed the Non-Wilful Maths, Not the Wilful Maths
In Bittner v. United States, the Supreme Court held in 2023 that the non-wilful penalty applies per report, not per account. Six missed years therefore cap non-wilful exposure at about $99,216 at current figures. However, Bittner did not touch wilful penalties, which still apply to each account. Hence the gap between a non-wilful and a wilful finding can run into millions. That gap, not the FBAR excessive fines debate, is where most cases are decided.
A Decision Framework for Americans in Britain With Missed FBARs
The lesson from Rund is that FBAR excessive fines litigation is a last resort. Instead, we work through three steps with every client who has missed FBARs, ideally before the IRS makes contact.
Step One: Honest Wilfulness Triage
First, we review every signed Form 1040 for the years in question, especially the answer on Schedule B Part III. A "no" answer while you held UK accounts is the single most damaging fact in Rund-style cases. Next, we establish what you told your preparer and when. Finally, we look for structuring, nominee arrangements or accounts opened after you learned of the rules. Each of these pushed Rund across the recklessness line.
Step Two: Choose the Route Before the IRS Chooses It for You
If the facts support non-wilful conduct and you meet the non-residency test, the IRS Streamlined Filing Compliance Procedures for taxpayers abroad carry no FBAR penalty at all. That outcome beats any constitutional argument. We prepare those submissions through our IRS Streamlined filing service. Where the facts point towards wilfulness, the IRS Criminal Investigation Voluntary Disclosure Practice is the formal route, and it needs specialist legal counsel alongside the return preparation. Note also that the IRS withdrew the Delinquent FBAR Submission Procedures on 1 July 2026, as we explain in our article on the end of the delinquent FBAR procedures.
Step Three: Build the Proportionality Record Early
If an examination is already open, the record you build now decides any later FBAR excessive fines argument. We document each account's balance by year, the tax actually lost, and any accounts where the fixed minimum would exceed the balance. Additionally, we check whether the six-year assessment period has closed for early years, as covered in our guide to how far back the IRS can go on FBARs. Notably, Rund lost partly because he raised only a total-penalty argument, so an account-by-account record must exist from the start.
Case Study: A London Banker With Four Unreported Accounts
This illustrative example uses realistic figures to show how the numbers interact. Daniel is a US citizen and managing director at a London bank, living in the UK since 2017. For calendar years 2020 to 2025 he filed US returns but no FBARs.
The Exposure
Daniel held four accounts. His Zurich account from an earlier Swiss posting averaged $2.8 million and peaked in 2023. In addition, his stocks and shares ISA averaged $350,000, his Barclays current account $150,000, and a cash ISA about $15,000. His highest aggregate balance, in 2023, was $3.9 million.
If the IRS treated him as wilful and applied its usual method, the penalty would be 50 per cent of $3.9 million, or $1.95 million. Across the 24 account-years, whose balances total about $19.9 million, that is roughly 9.8 per cent per account-year. That rate is below the 14 to 16 per cent the Fourth Circuit upheld in Rund. Therefore, a total-penalty FBAR excessive fines defence would very probably fail.
By contrast, the theoretical statutory maximum is far higher. The Zurich account alone could attract around $8.4 million over six years. Moreover, the Barclays account and the cash ISA each sit below the fixed minimum, so each could draw $165,353 a year. That is about $992,000 on a $15,000 cash ISA, which is exactly the kind of account-level penalty Schwarzbaum struck out. In total, the ceiling approaches $11.4 million.
The Outcome
Daniel's preparer had answered "yes" to the foreign account question but had never asked about Switzerland, and Daniel did not know an FBAR existed. Those facts supported a non-wilful position. Because he had lived outside the United States for well over 330 days a year, he qualified for the Streamlined Foreign Offshore Procedures. We filed three amended returns, six FBARs and a non-wilfulness certification, paying modest tax and interest after foreign tax credits. His FBAR penalty was nil, against a non-wilful maximum of $99,216 and a wilful exposure measured in millions. Had he waited for an IRS letter, that route would have closed. His best remaining argument would then have been a narrow FBAR excessive fines point on two small accounts.
How TaxYork Can Help
TaxYork provides comprehensive US tax return preparation and FBAR and FATCA compliance for high-net-worth Americans in the UK. We prepare catch-up FBARs, amended Forms 1040 and Form 8938 filings, and we prepare Streamlined submissions with a carefully documented non-wilfulness narrative. Furthermore, our US tax returns for expats service keeps your annual reporting correct, so the question of penalties never arises again.
Where a client is already under examination, we assemble the account-by-account balance schedules and tax computations that counsel needs. We also coordinate the UK side, including HMRC disclosure where UK tax is unpaid, and we apply US-UK treaty relief so that tax on UK income is not paid twice.
Conclusion
United States v. Rund confirms that the FBAR excessive fines defence is real but narrow. The Fourth Circuit assumed the Eighth Amendment applies, yet it still upheld a $2.9 million penalty because the IRS had used its moderate 50 per cent method. The courts remain split, the Supreme Court's Jouppi decision is pending, and an American abroad can be sued in almost any district.
For Americans in Britain with missed FBARs, the practical message is clear. Your strongest protection is a well-documented non-wilful position, filed before the IRS makes contact. Meanwhile, an FBAR excessive fines challenge helps mainly where a fixed minimum penalty swamps a small account. Therefore, act while every option remains open.
Contact Us
If you have unreported UK or offshore accounts, book a consultation with our team for a confidential review of your exposure and filing route. Email hello@taxyork.com or call 020 3488 8606. We will review your returns, accounts and history, and then prepare your catch-up filings on a fixed scope.
Disclaimer
This article provides general information about US federal and UK tax and reporting rules as they stand in November 2026. It does not constitute tax, legal or financial advice, and it is not a substitute for legal counsel in any examination or litigation. The case study is illustrative, and outcomes depend on each taxpayer's exact facts. Please obtain advice tailored to your circumstances before acting on anything discussed here. TaxYork accepts no liability for actions taken on the basis of this article without a formal engagement.
