Biodiversity net gain site on English farmland with long meadow grasses, wildflowers and a wooden post fence

Arable land turned into fenced meadow like this can generate biodiversity net gain units, which HMRC and the IRS both tax as income.

Listen to this article

Prefer to listen? Press play — pick a voice below.

Introduction: Biodiversity Net Gain Money Is Taxed Twice Before It Is Spent

Biodiversity net gain payments received by an American who owns land in England are taxable in both countries, and the two systems rarely agree on when or how. HMRC's technical note of 14 May 2026 says most receipts from selling biodiversity net gain units are income, usually trading income, while the IRS has published nothing on the subject at all. Consequently, a US citizen farmer who signs a 30-year habitat agreement can face UK tax spread one way and US tax collected another, with a foreign tax credit that does not line up.

Developers in England now pay landowners real money for habitat. A housebuilder that cannot reach the statutory 10% uplift on its own site buys units from someone who can, and the landowner commits to create and maintain that habitat for at least three decades. For a family farm, a single biodiversity net gain sale can be worth more than several years of arable profit.

That windfall is where our work starts. In our experience, American owners of English land handle the UK side well, because their land agent and accountant have seen these deals before. The US return, by contrast, is usually prepared by someone who has never heard of a habitat bank. This guide covers both sides, and it shows with real numbers where the money leaks.

Biodiversity Net Gain in Plain Terms

Biodiversity net gain is the legal requirement, under Schedule 7A to the Town and Country Planning Act 1990, that most new developments in England leave nature measurably better off than before, by at least 10%. Developers can deliver the gain on their own site, buy off-site units from a landowner, or, as a last resort, buy statutory credits from the government. The off-site biodiversity net gain market is the one that pays landowners.

Who This Guide Is For

We wrote this for US citizens and green card holders who own farmland or estate land in England, whether directly, through a farming partnership or through a UK company. It also applies to dual national US UK families where one spouse is American and the land sits in joint names. If you only own a home and a paddock, the market is unlikely to want your land. However, anyone with ten or more hectares of low-grade arable or improved grassland near a growing town should read on.

How Does the Biodiversity Net Gain Market Work for Landowners?

Landowners create habitat, have it measured with the statutory metric, legally secure it for at least 30 years, register it, and then sell the resulting units to developers. The developer pays once, usually upfront, and the landowner carries the cost and risk of managing the habitat for the full term.

The government's own guide to understanding biodiversity net gain explains the developer side. For a landowner, the process runs in a predictable order. First, an ecologist records the baseline value of the land. Next, you agree a habitat management and monitoring plan, which sets out exactly what you will plant, cut, graze and record. Then the land is tied up, either by a section 106 agreement with the planning authority or by a conservation covenant with a responsible body. Finally, the site goes on Natural England's register and the units become saleable.

The 30-Year Commitment Is the Tax Problem

The money arrives early and the work lasts decades. Typically, a developer pays the full price when its planning condition needs discharging, yet you will be spending on fencing, grazing, surveys and monitoring reports until the 2050s. Both tax systems have to decide whether that early payment is income now, income spread over time, or something closer to the sale of a right over land. Notably, they reach different answers for different reasons.

Selling Direct or Through a Habitat Bank

You can sell units yourself, or you can let an intermediary do it. Habitat banks often take a lease or another interest in your land, create the habitat themselves, and pay you a fixed annual sum. Alternatively, some simply contract with you to deliver units and pay you per unit sold. As we explain below, that structural choice changes the UK category of income and, in turn, the US character of the same money.

What Changed in August 2026

Amending regulations took effect on 6 August 2026. In particular, developments with a red-line boundary of 0.2 hectares or less are now exempt unless they harm onsite priority habitat, and off-site delivery for minor development now sits level with on-site delivery. The government has also said nationally significant infrastructure projects will come within the regime from November 2026. For sellers of biodiversity net gain units, the result is fewer small buyers but larger infrastructure demand.

How Does HMRC Tax Biodiversity Net Gain Receipts?

HMRC's position is that biodiversity net gain receipts are normally taxable as income, and usually as trading income. Capital treatment is reserved for unusual cases, such as compensation for permanently losing the use of land. The length of the agreement is relevant but, on its own, does not make the payment capital.

That is the core message of HMRC's technical note on ecosystem services, published on 14 May 2026. It covers income tax, corporation tax, capital gains tax, VAT and stamp duty land tax, and it deals with nutrient credits and woodland and peatland carbon as well. For most owners the note settled a long-running argument, and not in their favour. Many landowners had hoped to pay capital gains tax at 24% on biodiversity net gain money rather than income tax at up to 45%.

Trading Income, Property Income or Something Else

Where you keep farming the land, HMRC treats the receipts as part of your farming trade. Where the land is not part of any trade, the note relies on the commercial occupation rule in section 10 of the Income Tax (Trading and Other Income) Act 2005, so the income is still treated as trading income. However, if a habitat bank takes an interest in your land and pays you rent, those payments are property business income instead. Commercially occupied woodland is the one awkward exception, because it sits outside income tax altogether unless the habitat work ends the commercial occupation.

When the Receipt Is Taxed in Britain

Timing follows your accounts. Unincorporated businesses using the cash basis, which became the default for sole traders and partnerships from 2024/25, are taxed when the money arrives. Businesses on the accruals basis follow UK GAAP, and HMRC accepts that GAAP may require the income to be recognised upfront, spread across the agreement, or a mix of the two. In other words, two farmers with identical contracts can pay UK tax on very different timetables.

Costs You Can Deduct

Ecologist fees, the legal cost of the section 106 agreement or covenant, and the work of creating habitat are generally deductible against trading or property income under the normal rules. Where a cost is capital, it may instead form part of the base cost of the land for capital gains tax. Capital allowances may also be available on qualifying plant. Above all, keep every invoice, because the US return needs the same costs in dollars, sometimes in a different year.

Does VAT Apply to Biodiversity Net Gain Units?

Yes. HMRC treats tradeable biodiversity net gain units supplied by a VAT-registered person in the UK as standard-rated, so 20% VAT applies. Statutory credits sold by the government are outside the scope of VAT. A landowner who is not yet registered must watch the £90,000 registration threshold, which one unit sale can breach on its own.

Current rates are on the GOV.UK page for VAT rates. Most working farms are already VAT-registered, so the practical issue is the contract wording rather than registration. If the sale agreement is silent on VAT, the agreed price may be treated as VAT-inclusive. For example, a £500,000 price then contains £83,333 of VAT, and your net receipt falls to £416,667. Make sure the agreement says "plus VAT".

Stamp Duty Land Tax

A plain sale of units is not a land transaction, so no SDLT arises on the developer's payment for the ecosystem service itself. However, where the deal also grants a lease, an easement, an option or another chargeable interest in land, SDLT can apply to the consideration for that interest. Habitat bank leases deserve a careful look for this reason.

Why VAT Matters on the US Return

VAT is not an income tax, so it can never be claimed as a US foreign tax credit. On the other hand, VAT you collect and pay over to HMRC is not your income either. We therefore report the net-of-VAT price on the US return, and we reconcile it to the VAT return so the figures tie up if the IRS asks.

How Does the IRS Tax Biodiversity Net Gain Payments?

The IRS has issued no guidance on biodiversity net gain units, so the US answer comes from general principles. A US citizen is taxed on worldwide income, and the payment is almost always ordinary income, reported either on Schedule F as farm income, on Schedule C, or on Schedule E as rent. Capital gain treatment is possible only in narrow cases.

Why Ordinary Income Is the Likely Answer

A biodiversity net gain deal bundles two things: a time-limited restriction on how you use your land, and a promise to perform habitat work for 30 years. Payments for services are ordinary income. Likewise, US case law has long treated payments for temporary rights over land as closer to rent than to a sale. For instance, an IRS private letter ruling released on 5 September 2025, PLR 202536025, treated forest carbon credit payments to a timber REIT as akin to granting a term easement and as rents from real property. A private ruling binds only the taxpayer who asked for it, but it shows the direction of travel.

When Capital Treatment Could Arise

Permanent restrictions are different. Under the principle in Inaja Land Co. (1947), money received for a permanent easement can be treated as the sale of an interest in land, applied first against the basis of the affected acreage. A biodiversity net gain covenant that runs far beyond 30 years, or that permanently sterilises the land, therefore deserves a second look. Most English agreements, however, are drafted at the 30-year minimum, and a 30-year right is not permanent.

Which Form the Income Goes On

If you farm the land and do the habitat work yourself, the receipt belongs on Schedule F alongside your crop and livestock income, and the IRS Farmer's Tax Guide governs the deductions. If a habitat bank pays you rent for its interest in your land, the income belongs on Schedule E. Owners who hold the land through a UK company report the company's results on Form 5471 instead, which brings the controlled foreign corporation rules into play.

Timing on a Cash-Basis US Return

Most individual US returns use the cash method, so the full biodiversity net gain price is taxable in the year you receive it. Accrual-method taxpayers can defer part of an advance payment, but only to the following year. As a result, the US return almost never spreads a biodiversity net gain payment over 30 years, even where the UK accounts do.

Where the Two Tax Systems Collide

The UK and US systems collide on timing, on the category of income for the foreign tax credit, on the 3.8% investment tax, and on social security. Each collision has a fix, but only if it is spotted before the return is filed.

The Foreign Tax Credit Timing Mismatch

The foreign tax credit on Form 1116 only works when UK tax and US tax fall on the same income at broadly the same time. Unused credits can go back one year and forward ten. Consider a farm on the accruals basis whose UK accounts spread the receipt over 30 years. The US taxes the whole price in year one, when little UK tax has been paid. Meanwhile, the UK tax arrives over three decades, and credits from years 12 to 30 have no US tax left to absorb them. That is genuine double taxation, and our tax treaty and foreign tax credit service exists to model it in advance.

The Category Problem

Farm and trading income falls into the general category on Form 1116. Rent from a habitat bank for biodiversity net gain land is usually passive category income. Notably, UK property income taxed at 40% or 45% normally escapes the passive basket under the high-tax rule and moves to general, which helps. Even so, a landowner with both a direct sale and a habitat bank lease can end up with credits stranded in the wrong basket. Our guide to the foreign tax credit carryover explains how to keep those credits alive.

Net Investment Income Tax

The Net Investment Income Tax adds 3.8% to rents and other investment income once modified adjusted gross income passes $250,000 for a married couple filing jointly, or $200,000 for a single filer. The IRS position is that UK tax credits cannot reduce it. Habitat bank rent is therefore exposed, whereas income from a farming trade in which you materially participate is not. For that reason alone, the choice between selling direct and leasing to a bank has a US price.

Self-Employment Tax and the Totalisation Agreement

A US citizen farming in England would, on US rules alone, owe self-employment tax on a trading receipt. However, under the US-UK totalisation agreement, a self-employed person living in the UK pays only UK National Insurance. You should hold a certificate of coverage from HMRC to prove it. UK Class 4 contributions, in turn, cannot be claimed as a US foreign tax credit, because the agreement already prevents double social security tax. Our article on US-UK social security totalisation covers the paperwork.

Case Study: Selling Biodiversity Net Gain Units From an Oxfordshire Farm

This illustrative case uses rounded figures, 2026/27 UK rates and 2026 US rates, and an exchange rate of $1.30 to the pound. It is not a real client, but every mechanism in it is one we see in practice.

The Facts

An American couple, both US citizens and UK-resident for many years, farm 300 acres in Oxfordshire as a 50:50 partnership on the cash basis. They take 15 hectares of poor arable land out of cropping, convert it to species-rich grassland and register it as a biodiversity net gain site. The metric produces 20 units. A housebuilder buys all 20 at £25,000 each plus VAT, so £500,000 net, paid in a single sum in June 2026. Their baseline survey, ecologist, management plan and legal fees cost £45,000, and seeding, fencing and water supply cost a further £60,000 in the same year.

The UK Bill

The partnership's profit from the sale is £395,000, or £197,500 each. At that level each spouse loses the whole personal allowance, so each pays £7,540 at 20%, £34,976 at 40% and £32,562 at 45%: £75,078 of income tax. Class 4 National Insurance adds about £5,207 each. Together they pay roughly £150,156 of income tax and £10,414 of National Insurance on the deal, using the rates on GOV.UK's Income Tax rates page. For clarity we have left their ordinary farm profit out.

The US Bill

The couple file jointly. Their Schedule F shows $650,000 of receipts and $136,500 of costs, a profit of $513,500. After the $32,200 standard deduction, taxable income is $481,300, and US tax before credits is about $106,928. UK income tax of $195,203 in dollar terms is available as a credit, so US income tax on this income falls to nil. The surplus of roughly $88,275 is carried forward for up to ten years in the general category. Without the totalisation agreement, US self-employment tax on the same profit would have been close to $59,000, so the HMRC certificate of coverage is worth having on file.

The Alternative They Rejected

A habitat bank had offered a 30-year lease at £16,000 a year instead. In the UK that is property income, taxed at 45% on top of their other income, so £7,200 a year. In the US it is passive rent of $20,800 a year. The UK tax covers the US income tax comfortably, but the 3.8% Net Investment Income Tax of about $790 a year stays payable, roughly $23,700 over the term, plus Schedule E reporting every year until 2056. Ultimately, the couple sold direct, kept control of the land, and parked the excess credits for future years.

The Reporting Mistake to Avoid

The most damaging error in a sale like this is reporting it on Form 8949 as a long-term capital gain with nil basis. That lowers the headline US rate, but it also treats the receipt as passive investment income, pulls it into the 3.8% tax and leaves the UK tax, which was charged on trading income, sitting in the general basket with nothing to absorb it. The couple's US bill would then rise from nil to a five-figure sum on income the UK has already taxed at 45%.

Reporting Duties Beyond the Return

Money from a biodiversity net gain sale changes more than the tax figure. It moves balances, triggers new registrations and pulls the farm into new UK filing rules from 2026 and 2027.

FBAR and Form 8938

A £500,000 deposit into a UK farm account will almost certainly make that account reportable on the FBAR, which applies once your foreign accounts together exceed $10,000 at any point in the year. Partners with signature authority over a partnership account must report it even if the account is in the partnership's name. Read the FinCEN guidance on the FBAR and our FBAR and FATCA service. Form 8938 then applies to married couples abroad filing jointly with foreign assets above $400,000 at year end or $600,000 at any time; the thresholds are on the IRS Form 8938 page.

Making Tax Digital From April 2027

Making Tax Digital for Income Tax applies from 6 April 2026 to sole traders and landlords whose qualifying income exceeded £50,000, and from 6 April 2027 to those above £30,000. Qualifying income means gross trading and property receipts, not profit. A single unit sale can therefore push a farmer into quarterly digital reporting. HMRC's Making Tax Digital eligibility checker shows where you stand, and our piece on the Making Tax Digital deadline for American owners covers the US-side overlap.

Years With Costs but No Income

After a biodiversity net gain sale, you will spend money on habitat management every year with no matching receipt. In the UK those costs create losses or reduce other farm profit. In the US they reduce Schedule F income in later years. Keep the two sets of records aligned, because a mismatch between deductible years is one of the easiest ways for credits and losses to go astray.

Missed Years Can Still Be Fixed

Some owners only discover the US side after the money is spent. If a sale was left off a US return, an amended return with Form 1116 usually repairs it, provided the UK tax was paid. Where several years of US returns are missing altogether, our US tax return preparation service for expats handles the catch-up, including any missed FBARs.

Planning Before You Sign a Biodiversity Net Gain Agreement

The cheapest tax planning on a biodiversity net gain deal happens before the heads of terms are agreed. Once the money has been paid and the covenant registered, most choices are fixed.

Match the Payment Profile to Both Returns

If your UK accounts will spread the income, ask for staged payments tied to habitat milestones. Staged payments keep UK and US tax in step, so each year's UK tax has US tax to credit against. Conversely, a cash-basis farm that will pay UK tax upfront gains little from staging and can take the lump sum.

Choose the Structure With the US Return in Mind

Selling biodiversity net gain units direct inside your farming trade keeps the income in the general category and outside the 3.8% tax. Leasing to a habitat bank simplifies your workload, but it creates passive rent and annual NIIT exposure. Holding the land in a UK company adds Form 5471 and the controlled foreign corporation regime. Our guide to farming business tax for American owners explains how each structure behaves more generally.

Check the Contract Clauses That Drive Tax

Read the VAT clause, the payment schedule, the duration of the covenant, and any clause granting the buyer or a habitat bank an interest in your land. In particular, a covenant that runs well beyond 30 years can change the US character of the receipt. Similarly, stacking units on land already earning other environmental payments needs each stream assessed separately, as HMRC's note stresses. Our earlier article on carbon credits for American investors covers the investor side of the same market.

How TaxYork Can Help

TaxYork prepares US and UK tax returns for American landowners, farmers and estate owners in England, so both returns are built from one set of figures. We model a biodiversity net gain sale before contracts are signed, then report it consistently on Schedule F or Schedule E, Form 1116 and the UK self-assessment or partnership return.

Cross-Border Preparation From One Team

We handle UK partnership returns, VAT reconciliation and Making Tax Digital submissions alongside the US federal return, FBAR and Form 8938. As a result, the exchange rates, cost allocations and timing assumptions match across both countries, which is exactly what an examiner on either side looks for.

Repairing Past Returns

Where a habitat sale has already been reported wrongly, or not at all, we prepare amended US returns, recover stranded credits and file missed FBARs. For owners who have never filed US returns, we also manage complete catch-up filings.

Conclusion

A biodiversity net gain sale is one of the largest single payments many English landowners will ever receive, and for an American owner it lands on two tax returns at once. HMRC now says the money is income, usually trading income, with VAT on top. The IRS has said nothing specific, but ordinary income is the likely answer, taxed in full in the year of receipt.

Most of the cost of getting this wrong comes from mismatches rather than rates: UK tax spread over decades against US tax charged upfront, rent landing in the passive basket, the 3.8% tax nobody budgeted for, and FBARs triggered by the deposit. Settle the payment profile and structure first, sign the contract second, and file both returns from the same numbers.

Contact Us

If you own land in England and a developer or habitat bank has approached you, talk to us before you sign. To review your position confidentially, book a consultation with our cross-border team, or contact us about returns already filed.

Email hello@taxyork.com or call 020 3488 8606.

Disclaimer

This article provides general information about US and UK tax rules as at November 2026 and does not constitute tax, legal or financial advice. The case study is illustrative, uses rounded figures and an assumed exchange rate, and does not describe a real client. HMRC's technical note reflects HMRC's interpretation rather than the law, and the IRS has issued no specific guidance on biodiversity units. Tax outcomes depend on your individual circumstances and on the wording of your agreement, and the rules described may change. You should obtain advice tailored to your situation from a qualified professional before acting. TaxYork accepts no liability for actions taken on the basis of this article.

Frequently Asked Questions

Yes. HMRC's technical note of 14 May 2026 says biodiversity net gain receipts are normally taxable income, usually as part of a farming or other trade. Payments from a habitat bank that holds an interest in your land are property income instead. Capital treatment is limited to rare cases such as permanent loss of use of land.

For most landowners it is income. HMRC accepts that capital treatment can apply only exceptionally, for example where a payment compensates for permanently sterilising land. The 30-year duration of a typical agreement is relevant but not decisive. In the US, payments for a 30-year restriction plus habitat services are also likely to be ordinary income.

Yes, if you are VAT-registered. HMRC treats tradeable biodiversity net gain units supplied by a UK taxable person as standard-rated at 20%. Statutory credits sold by the government are outside the scope of VAT. Always state that the price is plus VAT, because a silent contract can make the price VAT-inclusive.

Off-site habitat must be secured for at least 30 years, through a section 106 agreement or a conservation covenant, and registered with Natural England. You must manage and monitor the habitat for the whole term. Some agreements run longer, and a much longer or permanent restriction can change the US tax character of the payment.

Yes. A US citizen or green card holder living in England reports biodiversity net gain payments on the US return, usually as farm income on Schedule F or rent on Schedule E. On the cash method the full amount is taxable when received. UK income tax paid on the same income can usually be claimed as a foreign tax credit.

Usually, yes, through Form 1116. UK income tax on the same income offsets US income tax, with unused credits carried back one year and forward ten. Problems arise when UK accounts spread the income over decades while the US taxes it upfront, and when rent falls in the passive basket. VAT and Class 4 National Insurance are not creditable.

Yes. Making Tax Digital for Income Tax looks at gross trading and property income. It applies from 6 April 2026 above £50,000 and from 6 April 2027 above £30,000, based on earlier tax years. A large unit sale counted within your trading or property income can bring a farmer into quarterly digital reporting.

Get in Touch

Ready to get
your US taxes
sorted?

Whether you need help with IRS Streamlined filings, annual US tax returns, or cross-border tax planning — our team is here for you.

View Contact Details

Send us a message