An executive signs papers beside a calculator, checking an SA110 tax calculation summary for a US return

The SA110 tax calculation summary shows what HMRC wants in January, so an American's Form 1116 needs the liability behind it, line by line.

Listen to this article

Prefer to listen? Press play — pick a voice below.

Introduction: Reading the SA110 Tax Calculation Summary as an American

The SA110 tax calculation summary is the two-page HMRC form that records the result of your UK tax computation, and box 1 on it is almost never the figure your US preparer should type into Form 1116. Box 1 shows what you still owe after PAYE, it includes items the IRS refuses to credit, and it mixes several tax years. If you copy it across, you can lose most of your foreign tax credit in a single keystroke.

We see this mistake with the SA110 tax calculation summary every January. A client hands over a tidy UK computation, someone picks the largest bold number on the page, and the US return shows a fraction of the UK tax actually borne. The reverse error happens too. A preparer adds box 1 to the PAYE figure and then adds the payments on account again, so the same pound of tax is claimed twice. Both errors are fixable, but only if someone takes the page apart line by line.

At TaxYork, we prepare the UK and US returns together for executives, founders and investors who live in Britain. This guide walks through each box on the 2025/26 form, explains which parts the IRS will accept, and shows a worked example with real numbers. It also covers the timing rules that decide which US year receives the credit.

Why the SA110 Tax Calculation Summary Matters for Form 1116

The SA110 tax calculation summary matters because it is the only place where HMRC's whole computation for the year is condensed into a handful of numbers. Your US return needs the UK tax that relates to each type of income, in the right US year, converted at the right exchange rate. The SA110 pages give you the raw material for that, but in a shape designed for HMRC's collection system rather than for the IRS.

Form 1116 asks a different question from HMRC. HMRC wants to know what cash it should collect on 31 January. The IRS wants to know how much creditable income tax you paid or accrued for the year, and on which income. Those two numbers overlap, yet they are rarely equal.

What the SA110 Tax Calculation Summary Actually Contains

The SA110 tax calculation summary is a supplementary page of the paper SA100 return, published by HMRC with a 54-page set of notes and a working sheet. You can download the current version from the GOV.UK page for the tax calculation summary. If you file online, HMRC's service or your commercial software performs the same calculation and produces equivalent figures, which most people later print as an SA302.

The Boxes on Page TC 1

Box 1 records total tax due before any payments on account, and HMRC states plainly that this may include Student Loan repayments, Class 2 NICs and Class 4 NICs. Box 2 records an overpayment instead. Boxes 3 and 3.1 isolate Student Loan and Postgraduate Loan repayments, boxes 4 and 4.1 isolate Class 4 and Class 2 National Insurance, box 5 shows capital gains tax and box 6 shows pension charges. Boxes 7 to 9 deal with tax collected through your PAYE code for other years, while boxes 10 and 11 let you claim to reduce next year's payments on account.

The Boxes on Page TC 2

Page TC 2 of the SA110 tax calculation summary is shorter but more dangerous for a US filer. Boxes 14 and 15 record increases or decreases in tax because of adjustments to an earlier year, such as loss carry-back or averaging for creative workers. Box 16 records any 2026/27 repayment you are claiming now. Box 17 is free text. Each of these entries can change the UK tax for a year you have already reported to the IRS, and that has consequences on the US side that we cover below.

Who Still Completes It by Hand

Very few people now fill in the SA110 tax calculation summary manually. However, the SA110 notes for 2025/26 confirm that the working sheet cannot be used if you have entries on the FIG regime pages, certain Foreign page boxes or several other supplementary pages. In those cases HMRC or an adviser does the calculation. Many Americans in Britain fall squarely into that group, so the figures they rely on come from software rather than from a hand-completed form.

Why Box 1 Is the Wrong Number for Your US Return

Box 1 of the SA110 tax calculation summary is the wrong number because it is a balancing figure, not a liability. It starts with your total UK income tax, adds capital gains tax, National Insurance and loan repayments, and then subtracts everything already taken off at source. What remains is the cash you owe on 31 January, which tells the IRS very little.

It Is Net of PAYE and Tax Deducted at Source

The working sheet reaches box 1 through a box labelled total tax taken off at source, which includes the PAYE shown on your P60. For a salaried executive, PAYE is usually the largest single tax payment of the year. Consequently, a box 1 figure of £40,000 can sit on top of £70,000 or more of PAYE that is just as creditable. Leave the PAYE out and the US return shows less than half of the real UK tax.

It Includes Charges the IRS Will Not Credit

Box 1 of the SA110 tax calculation summary also includes amounts that are not income taxes in the US sense. Student Loan repayments are repayments of a debt, not tax. Class 2 and Class 4 National Insurance are social security contributions, and the IRS Publication 514 on foreign tax credits states that no credit is allowed for social security taxes paid to a country that has a totalisation agreement with the United States. The UK has one. Our guide to the certificate of coverage for self-employed Americans explains how that agreement stops you paying both countries instead.

It Can Mix in Other Tax Years

On the SA110 tax calculation summary, box 7 captures underpaid tax from earlier years that HMRC collected through your current tax code. Box 8 captures 2025/26 tax that HMRC will collect next year. Meanwhile, the payments on account in box 11 belong to 2026/27, not to the year on the form. Each of these shifts tax between UK years, and therefore potentially between US years.

Taking the SA110 Tax Calculation Summary Apart, Box by Box

The practical method is to rebuild the creditable figure from the computation underneath the SA110 tax calculation summary, not from its totals. You want the UK income tax liability for the year, before tax taken off, plus capital gains tax, minus anything that is not a creditable income tax. Each component then needs to be tied to a type of income.

Income Tax Before Tax Taken Off

The working sheet reaches a figure called income tax due after tax reductions before it subtracts anything collected at source. That is your starting point. It already reflects UK foreign tax credit relief for US tax, which HMRC grants on the SA106 Foreign pages, so the figure is net of any credit Britain gave you. Our article on the SA106 Foreign pages for Americans explains how that UK-side relief is claimed.

Capital Gains Tax in Box 5

Capital gains tax is an income tax for Form 1116 purposes and is generally creditable. However, it only helps if the gain is foreign source under US rules. For a US citizen, a gain on personal property is foreign source only if your tax home is abroad and the UK tax on the gain is at least ten per cent, under section 865 of the Internal Revenue Code. A UK resident paying 18% or 24% on shares clears that test, so the tax counts towards the passive category in most cases.

Pension Charges and the Child Benefit Charge

Box 6 of the SA110 tax calculation summary covers pension savings tax charges, chiefly the annual allowance charge. It is levied as income tax, but on contributions that the US may never treat as your income at all. Tax on an amount that US law does not recognise as income falls into the general category under the base difference rule in section 904 of the Internal Revenue Code, where it often adds little. The High Income Child Benefit Charge sits inside the income tax figure and raises similar questions, which we address in our piece on the High Income Child Benefit Charge for American families. In both cases, document the position you take.

What to Strip Out Completely

From the SA110 tax calculation summary, remove box 3 and box 3.1 loan repayments, box 4 and box 4.1 National Insurance, and late payment interest or penalties shown on your statement. Interest and penalties are never creditable taxes. Additionally, if any part of the UK liability is under appeal, it is not creditable until the dispute ends, unless you pay it and make the provisional credit election in Treasury Regulation 1.905-1.

Matching the UK Year to the Right US Year

The UK year runs from 6 April to 5 April, so every UK computation straddles two US calendar years. Which US return receives the credit depends on whether you claim foreign taxes on the cash basis or the accrual basis. This choice matters more than any single box on the SA110 tax calculation summary.

The Accrual Basis

Under the accrual method, a foreign tax accrues in the US year in which the foreign tax year ends. The UK year 2025/26 ended on 5 April 2026, so its tax belongs on your 2026 US return, filed in 2027. The election comes from section 905(a) of the Internal Revenue Code, and once made it binds every later year. For a steady UK income it usually gives the closest match between income and tax.

The Cash Basis

Under the cash basis, each payment counts in the year you make it. PAYE deducted between April and December 2025 belongs to 2025, PAYE from January to April 2026 belongs to 2026, and the balancing payment on 31 January 2027 belongs to 2027. Payments on account count when paid, but only to the extent they turn out to match the final liability. The result is lumpy, as our guide to HMRC payments on account for American filers shows.

Exchange Rates

The exchange rate follows the same choice. Accrued taxes are generally translated at the average rate for the year to which the tax relates, which the IRS publishes on its yearly average currency exchange rates page. Cash-basis taxes use the rate on the date of payment. Furthermore, an accrued tax that remains unpaid 24 months after the end of the year is treated as refunded until you pay it, so a forgotten HMRC debt can quietly reverse a credit you already claimed.

Splitting the UK Tax Across Form 1116 Categories

Once you have the creditable total, you still need to divide it between the general and passive categories. A single blended percentage is the most common shortcut and one of the costliest. UK tax rates differ sharply by type of income, and the working sheet behind the SA110 tax calculation summary computes each band separately for exactly that reason.

Use the Band-by-Band Working Sheet

Sections 6 and 7 of the working sheet behind the SA110 tax calculation summary allocate your income to bands in a fixed order: non-savings income first, then savings, then dividends. Each slice carries its own rate. Those slice-by-slice figures are the best evidence for how much UK tax fell on wages, interest and dividends respectively. In our practice we attach that breakdown to the Form 1116 workpapers, because it answers the IRS's question directly rather than by approximation.

The High-Tax Kickout

UK savings income taxed at 45% and dividends taxed at 39.35% both exceed the top US rate of 37%. Passive income taxed above that level is moved into the general category automatically. That is not an election. It can, however, leave your passive basket empty in a year when you have passive carryforwards waiting to be used, a trap we explain in our article on foreign tax credit basket errors.

Tax the Credit Cannot Reach

Some US tax is out of reach of the credit altogether. Net investment income tax at 3.8% cannot be reduced by UK tax under current IRS practice, and US tax on US-source income is outside the limitation unless the treaty re-sources it. Therefore a client can pay heavy UK tax and still owe the IRS something, even with a perfectly prepared SA110 tax calculation summary and Form 1116. The IRS Form 1116 instructions set out the limitation mechanics.

Special Cases That Change the Figure

Several common situations alter the numbers on the SA110 tax calculation summary in ways a US preparer will not spot from the totals alone. Each one moves UK tax between types of income, between years, or out of the computation entirely. If any of them applies to you, the creditable figure needs extra work.

Scottish Taxpayers

If your main home is in Scotland, your wages, self-employment profits, rents and pensions are taxed at Scottish rates. For 2025/26 those run from a 19% starter rate through 20%, 21%, 42% and 45% to a top rate of 48% above £125,140. Savings income and dividends, however, stay on the rates that apply across the rest of the UK. As a result, the slice of tax falling on non-savings income is larger than it would be in London, and the split between your Form 1116 categories shifts with it. A blended average built on English rates will understate the general category for a Scottish earner.

FIG Regime Claims

A first-year arrival who claims the four-year foreign income and gains regime pays no UK tax on qualifying foreign income and gains. The SA110 tax calculation summary then shows UK tax only on UK income, while the IRS still taxes everything. There is simply no UK tax on the foreign items to credit. Worse, the claim removes your personal allowance and the capital gains annual exempt amount, which raises UK tax on UK-source income, and that extra tax may sit in a category where it does you little good. HMRC's notes confirm that the working sheet cannot handle FIG entries, so these computations always come from software or an adviser.

Property Gains Paid Within 60 Days

When you sell UK residential property, you report and pay capital gains tax within 60 days of completion through a separate property return. The gain then appears again on your Self Assessment return, and the earlier payment is credited against it. Consequently, box 5 can show a small residual figure even though most of the tax was paid months earlier. On the cash basis, the 60-day payment counts in the US year you made it. On the accrual basis, it still belongs to the US year in which the UK tax year ends, whatever the payment date.

Gift Aid and Pension Contributions

Gift Aid donations and personal pension contributions paid under relief at source extend your basic rate and higher rate bands. That pushes some income out of the 45% band into a lower one. The total UK tax falls, but so does the tax on the top slice of each type of income, which changes your category split. Meanwhile, a Gift Aid charge can arise if you donate more than your tax covers, and that charge is not tax on any income the US would recognise. Keep it separate in your workpapers.

Building a Reconciliation Your Preparer Can Defend

A creditable figure is only as strong as the papers behind it. An IRS examiner reviewing Form 1116 can ask you to prove the foreign tax, and a balancing figure from the SA110 tax calculation summary on its own will not satisfy that request. The answer is a short reconciliation pack, assembled once a year, which ties every dollar on the US form back to an HMRC document.

The Documents to Collect

Start with the full tax calculation for the year, either the SA302 or your software's computation, plus HMRC's tax year overview, which confirms what HMRC has recorded as paid. Add your P60 for the PAYE total, any P11D for benefits, and your Self Assessment statement of account showing each payment and its date. Where you filed on paper, keep a copy of the completed SA110 tax calculation summary and the working sheet itself. Our article on the SA302 tax calculation for Americans in Britain explains how to download those documents.

Reconciling the Statement to the Computation

Next, check that the statement of account agrees with the computation. The balancing payment should equal box 1 less any payments on account already made for the year. If the two do not agree, there is usually an HMRC amendment, a coding adjustment or a late payment penalty in the gap. Each of those needs a decision. An amendment is a redetermination, a coding adjustment may belong to another year, and a penalty is never creditable. Writing the answer down at this stage saves hours later.

Keeping the File

Finally, keep the pack with the US return for at least as long as a claim could be reopened. Because a foreign tax credit claim can run for ten years, that means a decade, not the three years most people assume. If you later move back to the United States, those files also support any carryforward you use against future foreign income. In our experience, the clients who keep this pack never face a long correspondence with the IRS over their credit, because the evidence is already organised.

Case Study: An American Director in London, 2025/26

Consider an illustrative client: an American finance director living in London, filing a 2025/26 UK return and a 2026 US return on the accrual basis. Her salary is £180,000, taxed through PAYE on a 0T code. She also has £20,000 of UK bank interest, £40,000 of dividends from UK-listed shares, a £60,000 gain on UK shares, and two children receiving Child Benefit.

The UK Computation

With income above £125,140, she has no personal allowance. PAYE on the salary is £67,203. The interest is taxed at 45%, giving £9,000. After the £500 dividend allowance, £39,500 of dividends at 39.35% gives £15,543. Her income tax is therefore £91,746. The High Income Child Benefit Charge claws back the full benefit of £2,251. Capital gains tax on £57,000, after the £3,000 annual exempt amount, is £13,680 at 24%.

What Box 1 Shows

Her SA110 tax calculation summary shows £40,474 in box 1. That is income tax and the child benefit charge of £93,997, plus capital gains tax of £13,680, minus PAYE of £67,203. Her first payment on account for 2026/27 is £13,397, half of the £26,794 income tax not collected at source. Capital gains tax is excluded from that instalment.

What Belongs on Form 1116

The creditable UK tax is not the £40,474 on her SA110 tax calculation summary. Before the child benefit charge, it is £91,746 of income tax plus £13,680 of capital gains tax, which totals £105,426. At an illustrative 2026 average rate of $1.33, that is about $140,217, compared with $53,830 if box 1 were used. The tax on salary, interest and dividends lands in the general category because of the high-tax kickout, and the capital gains tax stays passive. Whether the £2,251 child benefit charge is added is a judgement we document separately.

What the Mistake Would Have Cost

Had box 1 been used, the general category would have been short of roughly $86,000 of credit. Her 2026 US tax on the salary alone would then have been only partly offset, and she would have paid the IRS tens of thousands of dollars on income HMRC had already taxed at higher rates. Notably, the opposite error, adding the £13,397 payment on account as well, would have overstated her credit and invited an IRS adjustment with interest.

Common Mistakes and What to Do Next

Most errors with the SA110 tax calculation summary come from a handful of habits, and they are easy to spot once you know where to look. Fixing them early is cheaper than amending later, although amendments remain possible for longer than most people expect.

Mistakes We See Most Often

The first is using box 1 of the SA110 tax calculation summary or the balancing payment as the foreign tax figure. The second is including National Insurance, which no amount of argument will make creditable. The third is counting payments on account as tax of the year they are paid on the accrual basis, which double counts. The fourth is ignoring box 14 or box 15 adjustments, which change an earlier year's UK tax without anyone telling the US preparer.

When HMRC Changes the Figure

Any later change to the UK tax shown on your SA110 tax calculation summary, whether through an amendment, an HMRC enquiry or a loss carry-back, is a foreign tax redetermination. You must report it to the IRS on Schedule C of Form 1116 and, where your US tax changes, on an amended return. Our guide to amending a US expat return with Form 1040-X explains the mechanics. Helpfully, IRS Topic No. 856 confirms that a claim for additional foreign tax credit generally has a ten-year window rather than the usual three.

Missed Returns and Missing Computations

If you have missed UK returns or missed US tax returns, the problem compounds. Each late US year needs its own Form 1116, built from that year's UK computation. Where the UK return was never filed, there is no computation at all, and the US credit cannot be supported. In that situation, bring the UK years up to date first, then prepare the US returns from the finished UK figures. Overseas accounts that generated the interest also need checking for FBAR reporting to FinCEN.

How TaxYork Can Help

We prepare both returns in one workflow, so the person reading your SA110 tax calculation summary is the same person completing Form 1116. That removes the hand-off where most credit is lost. We rebuild the creditable figure from the working sheet behind your SA110 tax calculation summary, tie each slice of UK tax to its US category, apply your cash or accrual election consistently, and keep a reconciliation you can hand to the IRS if asked.

For clients with complex years, we also review boxes 14 to 16 for redeterminations, check that payments on account are not double counted, and test whether a carryforward is at risk of expiring. Our US tax returns for expats service covers the full US filing, and our FBAR and FATCA reporting service handles the account disclosures that sit alongside it.

Conclusion

The SA110 tax calculation summary is a collection document, not a credit document. Box 1 tells you what HMRC wants on 31 January. It does not tell the IRS what UK income tax you bore. To claim the full credit you need the liability before tax taken off, stripped of National Insurance and loan repayments, split by type of income, placed in the right US year and translated at the right rate.

Done properly, the SA110 tax calculation summary and the computation behind it become the strongest evidence on your US return. Done carelessly, it can cost a high earner more in a single year than a decade of professional fees. If your current preparer works from the balancing figure, it is worth asking how they reached the number on Form 1116.

Contact Us

If you want your SA110 tax calculation summary and the US foreign tax credit prepared together, book a consultation with our team. You can email hello@taxyork.com or call 020 3488 8606. We act for executives, founders and investors across the United Kingdom, including clients bringing missed UK or US returns up to date.

Disclaimer

This article gives general information about the HMRC tax calculation summary and the US foreign tax credit as at 19 November 2026. It is not tax, legal or financial advice for your circumstances, and the case study is illustrative rather than a real client. UK and US rules, rates and exchange rates change, and the right treatment depends on your full position in both countries. Take professional advice before acting. For general background, see HMRC's Self Assessment guidance on GOV.UK and the IRS foreign tax credit overview.

Frequently Asked Questions

The SA110 tax calculation summary is HMRC's supplementary page for recording the result of your Self Assessment calculation on a paper SA100 return. It shows tax due or overpaid, Student Loan repayments, Class 2 and Class 4 National Insurance, capital gains tax, pension charges and any claim to reduce payments on account. Online filers get the same figures from HMRC's system or software.

No. When you file online, HMRC's service or your software calculates the tax automatically and produces the same results. The SA110 tax calculation summary matters mainly for paper returns. However, Americans should still keep a full computation, because the US return needs the breakdown behind the totals, not just the amount due.

No. Box 1 of the SA110 tax calculation summary is the balance due after PAYE and other tax taken off at source, and it includes National Insurance and loan repayments. The creditable figure is your UK income tax and capital gains tax liability before tax taken off, minus non-creditable items, split by type of income.

No. Because the UK and US have a totalisation agreement, IRS Publication 514 bars any credit or deduction for UK social security contributions, including Class 2 and Class 4. Instead, the agreement decides which country's system covers you, and a certificate of coverage can remove US self-employment tax entirely.

On the accrual basis, UK tax for 2025/26 accrues on 5 April 2026, so it goes on your 2026 US return. On the cash basis, each payment counts when made, so PAYE splits between 2025 and 2026 and the January 2027 balancing payment falls in 2027. The accrual election is binding once made.

Accrued UK taxes are generally converted at the IRS yearly average rate for the year to which the tax relates. Cash-basis taxes use the exchange rate on the date you paid them. Whichever method applies, use it consistently and keep the source of each rate with your workpapers in case the IRS asks.

They are advance payments towards the next UK year, not tax of the year on the form. On the accrual basis they belong to the year they relate to, so adding them on top of that year's liability double counts. On the cash basis they count when paid, but only to the extent they match the final liability.

That is a foreign tax redetermination. You must notify the IRS using Schedule C of Form 1116, and amend the affected US return if your US tax changes. A claim for extra foreign tax credit generally has a ten-year window, so older years can often still be corrected.

Get in Touch

Ready to get
your US taxes
sorted?

Whether you need help with IRS Streamlined filings, annual US tax returns, or cross-border tax planning — our team is here for you.

View Contact Details

Send us a message