What HMRC Spotlights Are and Why Wealthy Americans Should Read Them
HMRC spotlights are the public warnings HM Revenue & Customs publishes about tax avoidance arrangements it believes do not work and intends to challenge. Each one describes how a marketed arrangement operates, explains why HMRC considers it ineffective, and tells anyone who has used it how to get out and settle. HMRC keeps the full set in its collection of tax avoidance schemes currently in the spotlight.
Most commentary on HMRC spotlights is written for British taxpayers alone. However, wealthy Americans in Britain sit in a different position, because every pound of UK tax they pay also counts on a US return. In our experience, an American client who buys a UK avoidance product often saves little or nothing, yet collects a new set of US filing duties along the way. This guide from TaxYork explains which spotlights reach American landlords, company owners and executives, and what each one does on both sides of the Atlantic.
How HMRC Spotlights Differ From the Named Schemes List
HMRC spotlights describe a type of arrangement, not a product. They do not name the promoter, the scheme or its users. In contrast, HMRC's separate list of named tax avoidance schemes, promoters, enablers and suppliers identifies specific businesses and branded schemes. Therefore, a client who checks only the named list for a promoter's brand can miss the fact that the underlying structure has already been flagged in a spotlight.
Furthermore, HMRC says plainly that absence from either list proves nothing. A scheme that has not featured in HMRC spotlights may still be challenged, and a scheme reference number on your return does not mean HMRC has approved anything. HMRC's own introduction to tax avoidance lists the warning signs it looks for, such as promised savings that sound too good to be true and arrangements with little real commercial purpose.
What HMRC Spotlights Do Not Tell You
Every spotlight is written from the UK point of view. None of them mentions the foreign tax credit, the American reporting forms, or the way US entity classification treats a British LLP or company. Consequently, the British warning is only half the story for a US citizen or green card holder. The other half, which this guide covers, is often the more expensive one, because American information-return penalties apply even when no US tax is due.
The HMRC Spotlights That Reach Wealthy American Households
HMRC has published more than seventy spotlights since the series began. Many target agency workers and umbrella company contractors, so they rarely touch the clients we serve. Several recent HMRC spotlights, however, aim squarely at landlords, company owners and senior employees, which describes much of the American community in London.
Property Landlords: Spotlights 63 and 63a
Spotlight 63a, published on 22 April 2026, extends HMRC's earlier warning on hybrid partnerships. Under the marketed structure, a landlord moves a rental portfolio into an LLP, adds a company as a corporate member, and uses indemnities over the mortgages so that profits flow to the company. Promoters claim the profits then bear Corporation Tax instead of higher-rate Income Tax, and that the restriction on mortgage interest relief falls away.
Like most HMRC spotlights, this one rejects every part of the promoter's claim. Specifically, it relies on the mixed member partnership rules in section 850C of ITTOIA 2005 to reallocate excess profit back to the individual. It also cites the transfer of income streams rules, the transparency of LLPs for capital gains, and the Stamp Duty Land Tax charges on transfers into partnerships. Additionally, an LLP with a company member that holds UK homes worth over £500,000 falls within the Annual Tax on Enveloped Dwellings, so missed ATED returns add penalties.
LLP Liquidations and Capital Gains: Spotlight 69
Spotlight 69, published on 28 April 2025, targets a different landlord product. The landlord contributes properties with large gains to an LLP, places the LLP into members' voluntary liquidation, and the properties then pass to a company the landlord controls. Promoters claim this wipes out the gain and avoids Stamp Duty Land Tax.
For liquidations entered into on or after 30 October 2024, section 59AA of TCGA 1992 treats the landlord as disposing of the property just before contributing it. Accordingly, the gain the scheme was meant to remove is taxed after all. HMRC also says it is considering the General Anti-Abuse Rule, which carries a 60% penalty for arrangements entered into after 14 September 2016. Among the recent HMRC spotlights, this is the one that most often surfaces in the portfolios of American landlords who come to us.
Company Owners: Spotlights 47, 62 and 68
Owner-managers face three HMRC spotlights in particular. Spotlight 47 covers attempts to wind up a company, extract its reserves as capital, and carry on the same business through a new company. The targeted anti-avoidance rule in section 396B of ITTOIA 2005 taxes such a distribution as income where the shareholder held at least 5%, the company was close in the two years before, and similar activity continues within two years afterwards.
Spotlight 68, published on 31 March 2025, deals with companies that pay a promoter for "advertising" and receive most of it back as loyalty points loaded onto directors' prepaid cards. HMRC treats the points as taxable income and challenges the company deduction and the VAT reclaim. Similarly, Spotlight 62 attacks share structures that route dividends to relatives so that school fees are paid from income taxed at lower rates, and HMRC treats those dividends as the owner's own income.
Why a UK Scheme Often Saves an American Nothing
Promoters price their products on the UK saving alone. For an American, that headline figure is misleading, because the United States taxes its citizens on worldwide income and then gives credit for UK tax paid. The interaction is the single biggest gap in the existing coverage of HMRC spotlights.
The Foreign Tax Credit Arithmetic
The IRS foreign tax credit lets you offset UK income tax against the US tax on the same income. Since UK rates on most income are higher than US rates, a typical London-based American pays no US tax on UK income and carries excess credits forward. Therefore, if a scheme lowers your UK tax, the first effect is simply to reduce those excess credits. Your total tax bill falls only by the amount that the UK rate exceeded the US rate. None of the HMRC spotlights mentions this effect, because each is written for a taxpayer who files in Britain alone.
Moreover, once UK tax drops below the US tax on the same income, the IRS collects the difference. In practice, an American who brings a UK effective rate on rental profit down to 25% may find that US tax at 32% or 35% fills much of the gap. The UK saving then becomes, in large part, a transfer to the US Treasury, while the UK legal risk stays entirely with the client.
Section 24 Already Has a US Answer
Landlord schemes under Spotlight 63a are sold mainly as a cure for the restriction on mortgage interest relief. Yet the US return already allows the full interest deduction on Schedule E, together with depreciation that Britain does not give. As our guide to section 24 mortgage interest for US landlords explains, the restriction usually increases UK tax and therefore increases your foreign tax credits. Consequently, an American landlord tends to feel the restriction less than a British landlord does, which weakens the commercial case for the scheme even before HMRC challenges it.
When the US Bill Rises Instead
In some structures the US outcome is worse than neutral. Profit diverted to a UK company is no longer your personal income for US purposes, but the company may be a controlled foreign corporation whose passive rental income can come back onto your return anyway. Likewise, a liquidation that the UK treats as capital may produce a US result that does not match it. We therefore model both returns before any client restructures or exits an arrangement described in HMRC spotlights, because a UK-only projection cannot show where the money really ends up.
The US Reporting a Spotlighted Structure Creates
Missed reporting is where Americans in spotlighted arrangements suffer most. The structures in HMRC spotlights usually add entities, and each entity has its own US form, deadline and penalty.
LLPs, Companies and Missed Reporting
US entity classification does not follow British labels. Under the default rules, a foreign entity whose members all have limited liability is treated as a corporation unless someone elects otherwise. Hence, a UK LLP that HMRC treats as transparent can be a foreign corporation for the IRS, requiring Form 5471 and raising controlled foreign corporation or even passive foreign investment company questions. If an election was filed, the LLP is a partnership instead and needs Form 8865.
The corporate member in a Spotlight 63a structure is a separate UK company, so it usually needs its own Form 5471. Each missing Form 5471 or Form 8865 carries a $10,000 penalty under section 6038, rising by $10,000 for every 30 days after an IRS notice, up to a further $50,000. Additionally, the LLP's and company's bank accounts may bring new FBAR filings with FinCEN and Form 8938 entries if you have signature authority or a qualifying interest. Our FBAR and FATCA reporting team sees these gaps regularly when a client first shows us a structure a promoter set up.
Is a Spotlighted Scheme Reportable to the IRS?
An entry in HMRC spotlights does not make an arrangement a US listed transaction. However, the US rules on Form 8886 reportable transactions apply on their own terms. For an individual, a confidential arrangement with a minimum fee of $50,000, a contractual fee refund if the savings fail, or a section 165 loss of $2 million or more in a year can each trigger a filing. Our article on DOTAS scheme numbers and Form 8886 covers that overlap in detail. Failing to file can cost up to $10,000 per transaction for an individual, and up to $100,000 if the transaction is listed.
Liquidations and Related-Party Sales
Spotlight 69 structures often end with properties passing to a company the landlord controls. For US purposes, a sale of depreciable property between related persons falls under section 1239, which treats the whole gain as ordinary income rather than capital gain. Consequently, an American can face a US charge at ordinary rates on a transaction designed to avoid UK capital gains tax entirely. Equally, under Spotlight 47 a UK income charge on a liquidation may meet a US capital gain, and the two must be aligned carefully so the foreign tax credit reaches the right income.
What Happens When HMRC Challenges the Arrangement
The message across the HMRC spotlights is consistent. If you have used the arrangement, it will open an enquiry, seek the full tax and interest, and charge penalties where they apply.
Enquiries, Notices and Penalties
Where a return is still open, HMRC opens an enquiry. Where the scheme carried a scheme reference number, it can also issue an accelerated payment notice, which demands the disputed tax within 90 days before any tribunal decides the point. Our guide to the accelerated payment notice for US filers explains how that cash demand interacts with the US return.
Inaccuracy penalties run up to 30% for careless errors, 70% for deliberate ones and 100% for deliberate and concealed ones, before the offshore uplifts. In addition, the General Anti-Abuse Rule adds its own 60% penalty where HMRC counteracts an abusive arrangement. Promoters who fail to disclose under DOTAS face penalties of up to £600 a day, rising to £1 million, but that money never reaches the client.
Time Limits and Interest
HMRC can normally assess within four years, within six years for careless behaviour and within 20 years for deliberate behaviour. Late payment interest runs at the Bank of England base rate plus four percentage points, the rate in force since 6 April 2025. Therefore, a scheme used for several years builds up a meaningful interest bill even when HMRC accepts that the client acted carelessly rather than deliberately.
What the Later UK Tax Does to Your US Return
When you eventually pay the UK tax the scheme was meant to avoid, the US return for those years becomes wrong too. Under Treasury Regulation section 1.905-4, an increase in foreign tax is a foreign tax redetermination, and you claim the extra credit by amending the affected years on Form 1040-X. Helpfully, section 6511 gives a ten-year window for refund claims based on foreign tax credits. As our article on foreign tax redeterminations explains, the UK interest and penalties are never creditable, because the regulations do not treat them as tax.
Case Study: The London Landlords Who Paid Twice for Nothing
The following illustrative case combines features we see often in structures caught by HMRC spotlights. The figures are simplified and use an exchange rate of $1.30 to the pound.
The Arrangement They Bought
A married couple, both US citizens living in London, owned six buy-to-let flats worth £3.6 million in total with £1.4 million of mortgages. Gross rents were £180,000 a year, mortgage interest was £70,000, and other costs were £20,000. As additional-rate taxpayers, they paid UK tax of roughly £58,000 a year on the rents, because section 24 limited interest relief to a 20% credit of £14,000.
In 2023 a promoter sold them a hybrid LLP with a corporate member of the kind later described in HMRC spotlights 63 and 63a. The promoter projected Corporation Tax of £22,500 a year instead of £58,000, a claimed saving of £35,500 a year, for an upfront fee of £45,000. Nobody mentioned the US return.
What HMRC and the IRS Did
After Spotlight 63a appeared, the couple came to us. On the UK side, the mixed member rules meant the "saved" £35,500 a year was still owed for three years, a total of £106,500. Late payment interest added roughly £12,000. HMRC accepted that the behaviour was careless and that the disclosure was prompted, and it charged a 15% penalty of about £15,975. The £45,000 fee was gone. Altogether, the arrangement cost about £179,475 more than doing nothing.
On the US side, the outcome was even starker. Before the scheme, their UK tax on the rents already exceeded the US tax on the same income, so their US liability on the rents was nil and excess credits were carrying forward. The scheme therefore never saved them a single dollar of US tax. Meanwhile, nobody had filed Form 5471 for the LLP, which defaulted to corporate status, or for the corporate member. With two forms a year for three years, the exposure reached $60,000 before any continuation penalties.
We prepared the late information returns with a reasonable cause statement explaining the reliance on the promoter, and we amended the affected years to claim the extra UK income tax as a foreign tax credit redetermination. Because the couple already held excess credits, the amendment mainly increased their carryforward rather than producing a refund. The lesson is simple: a UK saving that the IRS would have absorbed anyway is not worth any UK risk at all.
Getting Out of a Spotlighted Arrangement
Exiting cleanly means fixing both countries in the right order. In our experience, clients who settle the UK position first and then correct the US returns spend far less than clients who try to unwind the structure quietly. The same order applies whichever of the HMRC spotlights describes your structure.
A Five-Question Test Before You Sign Anything
We ask every American client five questions before any UK restructuring goes ahead. First, does the arrangement depend on a company, LLP or partnership you would not otherwise need? Second, does it promise a saving well above what a plain change of ownership or timing could achieve? Third, has the structure, or anything resembling it, appeared in HMRC spotlights or on the named list? Fourth, what does the projected UK saving become once the foreign tax credit and the new US forms are included? Fifth, will the promoter put its US analysis in writing and stand behind it? If the answer to the first three is yes, or the promoter cannot answer the last two, we recommend walking away.
Settling With HMRC and Correcting the IRS
Each of the HMRC spotlights gives a contact route for users who want to settle, and Spotlight 63a and Spotlight 69 each give a dedicated HMRC email address. Settling usually means withdrawing from the arrangement, declaring the income or gain as HMRC says it should have been taxed, and paying the tax, interest and any agreed penalty. Where earlier UK returns were never filed because the scheme claimed nothing was due, the work also becomes a catch-up of missed UK tax returns.
The US correction then follows. You file the missing information returns, amend the years where foreign tax has increased, and check whether any account opened for the structure needs a late FBAR. Our US tax returns for expats team prepares that package alongside the UK settlement figures, so both governments see a consistent story. Where the structure also distorted double tax relief, our tax treaty optimisation service makes sure the credit lands in the right category and year.
How TaxYork Can Help
TaxYork prepares US and UK tax returns for high-net-worth Americans in Britain, dual nationals and accidental Americans, and we deal with the compliance fallout when a UK arrangement goes wrong. When a client comes to us with a structure that appears in HMRC spotlights, we map every entity it created and settle the UK position. We then prepare the missed US reporting and amend the affected federal returns so the foreign tax credit follows the UK tax actually paid.
Because we prepare both countries' returns, we can show you in pounds and dollars what an arrangement really saved before you decide anything. Furthermore, we handle the FBAR, Form 8938, Form 5471 and Form 8865 filings that promoters routinely leave out.
Conclusion
HMRC spotlights are short, practical warnings, and wealthy Americans in Britain should read them before signing any planning proposal. The landlord, liquidation and profit-extraction schemes they describe rarely work in the UK. Moreover, for a US citizen, much of the promised saving would have gone to the IRS even if they had worked, while the new entities create US reporting with five-figure penalties.
If you have already used an arrangement that resembles one of the HMRC spotlights, act before HMRC opens an enquiry. A prompted disclosure costs more than an unprompted one, and a US information return filed late with a strong explanation is far cheaper than one the IRS finds first.
Contact Us
If you are worried about a structure you have used, or you want a second opinion on a proposal before signing, book a consultation with our US-UK team. You can also email hello@taxyork.com or call 020 3488 8606. We will review the arrangement against the current HMRC spotlights and model its effect on both of your returns.
Disclaimer
This article provides general information about US and UK tax rules as they stood on 10 November 2026. It is not tax, legal or financial advice, and it does not create a client relationship. The case study is illustrative, its figures are simplified, and it assumes an exchange rate of $1.30 to the pound. HMRC may publish new spotlights or update existing ones at any time. Tax outcomes depend on your full circumstances, so please obtain professional advice before acting on any information in this article.
